It amuses me that I knew about this quest for at least a year before discovering the Randomizer romhack. Anyway...

For those of you First Quest junkies or anyone who just really likes old-school Zelda, I highly recommend playing this. Clocking in at 54 standard dungeons plus a few extra goodies, this quest will last about 25-30 hours for a decent Zelda player, if you're lucky enough to find the Lens early on! Which brings me to my biggest problem with this quest: It's a very old-school experience and it's not really built for the kinds of people who like a straightforward Zelda experience. Most of the dungeons are hidden behind bombable walls and burnable bushes (or worse, Whistle stairs), which makes them hard to find and keep track of even with the overworld map. You practically need to write the locations of things down when you find them, and some of the later dungeons are needlessly convoluted layout-wise and likewise require mapping efforts. (I'm looking at you, EX1-9 and EX2-9!) That being said, I love how much content this quest has to offer. It's always nice to discover a new item and wonder what the heck it does, and whether you're blitzing through the game or going for 103% like I did, looting dungeons is really its own reward.

The dungeon music is varied enough to never really grate on you, unless you really dislike one of the tunes you're presented with, in which case whatever I guess. And the addition of several ZC2.5 and custom enemies shakes up the usual experience just enough to be interesting. I personally found myself switching between items very frequently while navigating the dungeons, as I didn't get the higher-tier swords until late in the game. (In fact, the final sword was the very last item I found aside from the reward for 103% completion! Talk about obscure!)

Viewing the quest as a whole, I highly recommend this to anyone who has the patience and mental agility for a Zelda-themed collect-a-thon and I've got high expectations for the later Randomizers!

This is the definite version of Randomizer: It addresses a flaw seen in Modern concerning dungeon exits. Now, you can warp to both overworlds using warps seen in the overworld. It also adds a counter to how many items you've collected so far in the quest, a new set of dungeons, and a whole bunch of new items.

Randomizer Super is a very long quest. Memorizing the dungeon layouts and where items are will help you immensely in subsequent play-throughs. If you don't like long quests that can be taxing after a while, this may not be the quest you'd like. I also want to give kudos to some of the scripts used in this quest to make it fresh and unique.

Overall, it's an excellent quest that you should play at least once. You won't regret it, I promise.

Randomizers are always fun in my book, and this one has tons of content to sink your teeth into. great quest.

I agree with Jamian's review. The treasure hunting expedition (2-overworlds-60+-dungeon-and-secrets-on-every-overworld-screen) becomes boring after a while. I hate to say it, because it's a good quest, but getting all of the items becomes a chore in dungeons that have one-way doors and secret passages that lead back to the beginning.

But it's addictive for sure and a well-executed concept.

Like the other randomizers, this is highly replayable since you never know which items you're going to get, and every playthrough will be different. The concept in itself is excellent.

But like the other randomizers, you can feel a drop in quality when you compare the original Zelda 1st and 2nd quest levels with the (too) many new levels. They abuse unmarked secret passages, requiring you to constantly use the lens, or to randomly bomb / try to walk through every single wall. With 60ish dungeons to visit, this ends up being tedious. I would prefer a shorter and tighter randomizer quest using only the original Zelda levels.

Still, the unusually high replayability makes me want to give it a 4/5.

I love the idea of these Randomizers but I feel like the items and dungeons are bloated. Is there any chance you will ever put one out that just remixes the standard items and the levels from the first (and maybe second) quest? Thanks!

My starting weapon: Wooden Sword. I search the overworld and I find the Blue Ring and White Sword. I go into Level 1-1 and find the Red Ring, Magic Sword, and Mirror Shield. Man, am I lucky!

I found and completed 59 dungeons. I found one other dungeon which led to a "gold" dungeon, but I had to quit and now I can't find it. Is the final dungeon? If so where am I supposed to be looking? It's driving me crazy!

As if the Modern Randomizer wasn't fun enough...gonna give this one a shot and see what new secrets to find.~

Been looking forward to this. Gonna try it out.