Some good, some notsomuch, but why are there Rupees?

The Star, Goomba, and Bullet Bill are weak. Everything else is good, though.

No opinion
you go to the middle of the road
6/1o
3 *'s

Hmm, let's see... Good ? blocks and note blocks. In fact, most of the ripped stuff is good, except for the regular brick. That's the SMB3 brick block, I believe, and it would look a LOT better if you ripped the whole animation.

The custom-drawn stuff, however... well, the Goomba doesn't look very good. It needs an outline, and it's too narrow from the side. Goombas are round, even if they look flat in SMB games where they only face forward. Bullet Bill really needs to be ripped, though the shape of your up/down tiles are just right. The sideways hammer looks great, although I wonder if it really animates correctly (haven't tried it). The "up" animation for the hammer is way too narrow, but otherwise pretty good. You need a "down" hammer anim.

Overall, it's an even 3; could be a solid 4 if you make some improvements/additions. By the way, did you mean to imply that these are NOT rips when you mentioned "stenciling from game manuals"? If so, then that shows hard work.

umm... good job?
Its just that the goomba whil walking left or right, he is too skinny.

Drawn by hand from ingame images. That's an interesting way of ripping...

Overall good job. The up/down hammer sprites, the left/right goomba sprites, and the snifits (mouth mainly) are the things that need the most work.