Ah crap I'm up against two magnificent shots: MountainDrew and PrettyBoy. If only i had been warned sooner...
MD: Crap, that's awesome. That's the best use of a Mario tileset yet
Blonde799: Bleh. I like the colors, and the plant growth makes it look interesting, but this shot is too plain as a whole.
Polygon X8: See Blonde's description, only without the plant growth
PrettyBoy: Is that a Wind Waker quest? That King of Red Lions is awesome, as is the rest of the tileset.
codelinker: Well, all I can say is that the tree and brush areas don't meld well with the dungeon walls at all. Otherwise, it looks very good.
jman2050: That harp took me forever to make, and it still isn't perfect... ah well, it's good enough that most anyone not looking won't notice anything wrong with it. BTW, this is 100% MSPaint

link3505 and BH4: The tiles themselves look nice, but those are NOT the right colors to use, and completely knocks down the shots.
Null vote as usual, though I can probably predict who will be the winner (and no, it's not me

)