30 replies to this topic

[PrinceMSC]

Drari


LinktheMaster

Sprites still pending.

venom343

the gang's all here

[LinktheMaster]

Drari: Very nice. Except there's a lot of missing detail. The moth would look better if it's parts weren't one solid color (mainly the wings). Also the ground could look better. It seems rather... empty.
venom343: Like I said about Drari, the ground is a bit empty. It would help if you didn't center your grass and flowers around in specific spots.

Small week this round. Guess it was a good time for me to get in.

***null vote***

[link3505]

I voted for LtM. while I liked the colors on Drari's, the layout just didn't look natural. and Vemon's did feature Kirby and Link with a lawnmower (always a good combination), there just wasn't enough detail

[Exate]

Shots 1 and 3 are missing detail for a better screen, and LTM's... sorry, but that gray BG at the top kills it for me.

*null vote*

[Anthus]

I voted for Drari.

I like the custom boss, and it is detailed. There may not be something on every grass tile, but it is stil really good.

(so sue me )

[Highsight]

I liked Drari's. It has some pretty good custom tiles.

[drari]

Uhh Linkman, the only custom tiles made by me were the map, the things on the bottom, and the shadow, everything else i found on this site.
Anyway....
LTM's shot- The shot is pretty good,but the BG does look strange.
Venom's shot- The shot is a bit plain but I like the custom tiles, espically the dog.
null voted*

Edited by drari, 10 April 2005 - 04:49 PM.

[FireStorm]

I null voted. To be honest, none of the shots really captured me as "SotW worthy." I like LTM's the best, but they all lack a unique punch other shots have. I've seen all the tilesets before. Not that they all don't have good designs, but the point of SotW is to judge the graphics ONLY (or that is what I've inferred about it).

[Hero_of_Hyrule]

Well, I kind of liked Drari and LinktheMaster's shots about the same...so I null voted. As for venom343's shot...I liked the custom tiles, but the rest was just to bland and boring.

[LinktheMaster]

I've seen all the tilesets before. Not that they all don't have good designs, but the point of SotW is to judge the graphics ONLY (or that is what I've inferred about it). 

Well, sorry, but not everyone can pull out a new tileset everyweek.

Really, it depends on people. Some of us (including myself) bring other things into the picture, such as setup, attention to detail and creativeness. Setup is the ways of accessing and exitting the area (so a normal 2 way entrance woulnd't win here), detail is adding flowers and other grass, and other colors to bring up the pics), and creativeness is using old tiles in a different way. Remember Radien's Link house? It was mostly old tiles, but he used them in a new way. New graphics do add to it, but I try not to pay attention to them as the only thing there.

[lord_jamitossi]

I voted drari because of the custom boss, but this week seems a little lower quality than most. Hopefully next week things will pick up a bit again.

[Zemious]

I find that these three are very good althought the first one cought my eye the most.

I have to say that I like the custum boss alot, I also think you put a great deal into the map border to the top left. I think that you did a great job Drari but I think that there are some parts in your screenshot that I dislike.
I think that the screen lacks a bit of detail, there is alot of detail in your custum boss and in your border map and the border of your A and B but you need ALOT more detail on the ground.
You need some grass tiles, you could try using ALttP grass and bush tiles, they look great, defently not the same in pure set. I believe you are going for a "fall" effect with all the brown leaves on the ground, you could try having some more to add a bit more detail.

LinktheMaster, I can't really see your screenshot too much but I see you added in a custem link tile which looks moderately nice. It would fit more if you were using a tileset such as Poke'mon but this still, I see some preatty decent stuff there.

And last but not least venom343, your is really good when it comes to your sprites but what is with your door step? You should have BH4 or a tile specialist make you a rug or somthing for your door, that rock tile infront of your house door has to go unless you are intending it to be a sidewalk of some sort but hey its your quest.
I am not attacking anyone I am just lending out some constructive critism.
Great work everyone!

Drari got my vote.

[venom343]

oh no i got no votes onyway i voted for Drari because of the boss and the mountain tiles and stuff. as for linkthemasters shot , i liked that to but drari's boss just cought my eye.

[drari]

Can you vote even though you entered? Anyway thats not my mothula, it's System Error's, it's in the Misc. tiles section of this site.

Edited by drari, 11 April 2005 - 05:12 PM.

[LinktheMaster]

You can, but most people frown apon it.