Posted 14 October 2007 - 03:42 PM
This week deserves a lot of talk from me. In fact, I will even rate them holistically.
Bowser Blanchette - Looks like something I have seen before. It is not bad, and is in fact a well thought out block puzzle which saves it from getting an average to below average rating for me. 6/10
CastChaos - The custom boss is the main focus here, and it simply looks awesome. The rest of the screen is nothing special, but I don't think that will hurt this screen too much. 7/10
Ebola Zaire - I love those tiles. They all seem to work well together and you seem to put them together well too. This screen makes me curious to see the rest of the dungeon, so that is big plus. 8/10
gray0x - I generally like the combination of lava with those floors, walls, and the rest of the cosmetics. Interesting subscreen portion too. There is potential for at least a little more detail though. 6/10
Link75 - While it lacks the uniqueness found in the last three screens, the overall design is excellent. Everything mends together well enough to result in a complete overworld screen that rivals many designed by some of the best quest makers. 7/10
NoeL - Now this is definitely something completely new to me. While going two colors is nothing new and always risky, you seem to be approaching it in a new way. This approach hasn't made me go ga ga, but perhaps it just needs more time to grow on me. I would have to see more of it in the future of course, if you continue to have the drive for it. 7/10 for now at least, but I see potential for later screenshots that would do the same.
TriMaster001 - Also something I have seen before, although not the most commonly seen thing by a longshot. It certainly makes you think, and the creation of this screen was definitely well thought out. 7/10
My vote goes to Ebola Zaire.