5 replies to this topic

[Adem]

After a long time of not playing Zelda and Focusing on Tales of the Abyss, I beat it. Awhile later I had this feeling that made me want to play twilight princess. I saw a little bit about windwaker on a site I was on, and now I have this urge to start a new game on windwaker. What should I do?

[Mr. Pimpy]

TP, 10, 10.
I think they're both tens, though I like twilight better...

[Moonbread]

I say play Wind Waker. TP is good, but Wind Waker is my favorite of the 3D Zelda series. I mean, huge overworld, and more sidequests to do.

[Adem]

The whole "Tears of light" and "Your the chosen one so you have to be a wolf wheather you like it or not in TP bug me. Also, the dungeons are very defficult at certain moments. Windwaker has it's downsides too. Until you get the stupid song of storms, you have to go on half our ship rides and defeat enimies along the way, then you find out you went the wrong direction. On top of that, the dungeons are a little too easy.

That's why I have this little problem. Sorry Moon Whisper, but I think I'll go with TP.

[Comix]

Windwaker will last longer. There isn't much to do after you beat TP but WW just keeps going with many different sidequests and a LOT of places to explore.

[Mitchfork]

Twilight Princess
Pros: Great graphics, involving storyline, tight gameplay, moderate-hard difficulty.
Cons: Little replay value and lack of sidequests.

Wind Waker
Pros: Colorful, vibrant graphics, great replay value, interesting battles.
Cons: Too much time spent on ocean, pitiful difficulty, extremely predictable storyline (for me, anyway).

I'd go with TP. The graphics and gameplay were both a lot better.... still WW wasn't that bad of a game either. Whichever one you choose, I think you'll be satisfied.