I'm sorry to the others who entered, I didn't have much time last night to analyze these shots and give my thoughts on them, lets do so now.
Nekoishi: The perspective looks off to me. I really like the idea here, but it's a bit too confusing. I'm not sure if you could even add back drops to those tiles to give them the floating effect, since most of the tiles are already dark.
joelmacool12: Looks good to me, nice firebird? screenshot. You're going to have to step up your game though, now that this tileset is being used a lot, you're going to need to do amazing things to really stand out. Something creative.
Dwarlen: This shot is great to me, I'm a sucker for dark nights with snow. If it wasn't for Moosh, I'd have voted here. It's not just a cool idea to me, but I like the design as well.
Moosh: I know how capable you are Moosh, I love your scripts and your creativity. I'm glad we have people like you around who keeps bringing new ideas and scripts to ZC for all of us to use and build onto. Can't wait to face this boss in ZC some time. My vote went here.