31 replies to this topic

[NoeL]

EZ, for something different.

[Eddard McHorn Van-Schnuder]

Yes, I like EZ's too...
Great shot!

[Old Inactive Member]

Hard choice.
Evan - I very much love your palette and your design and graphics.
Billy - Plain dungeon shot. Not much to comment on. Could use detail. Inverted Stone Tower had open floors to the sky. I think you should take more advantage of that.
grayOx - The graphics are nice but the layout isn't. I like closed off corners (or at lease three). The trees are almost all on the same horizontal path. Spread them out.
Ebola - Very unique. The colors mesh really well with the classic set. Pretty good design too.
CC - Very good. I don't like those upside down chest though. The chest up there is cool though. I like the split walls. I don't like the messy-ness. Yes, I know, It's detail, but it's a house. Not everyone's house has stuff thrown all over the ground. The rest I like. I actually like the carpet.
Nuvo - Nice shot. Simple, but I like the wrap-around look. It has nice feel to it. Not much to say but good job

I vote for...umm...I'll think about it. I'll edit in my vote.
Yeah but that cloure isn't in my DGn plaeet and going back now would be a pain but mabey if i'm ahead of scheual
Wait i could replace some areas with sky thanks for reming me about that

I decided Evan. Ebola was so close though. I almost clicked it.

gray0x: Very nice tiles. The screecshot is to open though.
Evan the Great: I love the pallete!
Billy Ronals: That darkness looks great!
Ebola Zaire: Without a doubt, the best classic shot I have ever seen. My vote goes here.
CastChaos: It looks very messy, just like my room.
Nuvo: The best BS shot I have seen.

I hate to pint this out but ummm you speeled my name wrong

(and yes i did vote for myself aging this week but there are some great shots i almost didn't)

[The Grim Reaper]

I voted gray0x

[The Satellite]

Ah, heck, I thought they were all good, except billy's and gray0x's, which are about average.

However, I still think Evan's is the best, Ebola close second.

[Moonbread]

Dammit! Ebola does something classic and gets pooploads of votes? I hate myself.

Err, still had to vote for him

[Mitchfork]

Repaletted Classic with mountain usage befitting a more detailed style. Don't forget that!

[Dawnlight]

Evans is like the best of Pure, Ebola's is like the best of Classic, and Nuvo's like the best of BS.

[LostInHyru1e]

Ebola Zaire, hands down. I love it!

Nuvo, CastChaos, and Evan's shots were also very good.

Billy - Darkness looks cool, but a regular dungeon shot doesn't deserve to win.

Gray - I don't really like the screen design, or the tileset. Sorry...

Edited by LostInHyru1e, 23 November 2007 - 07:02 PM.

[Echo]

I voted for Ebola Zaire. His screen design appeals to me the most. And also you would think that because of the tiles he his using that would be a step backwards, but somehow its not. Great job Ebola Zaire!

[Nathaniel]

gray0x - 5/10
Nice choice of graphics and nice Link sprite, but I don't find the lower right and upper left to be all that appealing. Perhaps more detail can be added to the grass as well. The rest is not bad though.

Evan the Great - 7/10
Nice choice of tiles and nice usage of them. A standard forest screen that I would expect to see in any higher quality quest.

billy ronald - 5/10
You seem to be getting better. While the screen isn't the most extravagant, it does work well for a decent quality quest. I am not sure how I feel on the subscreen portion. I suppose I will need to think about it more. While most of the screen is pretty dark, it looks like it's intended to be that way.

Ebola Zaire - 7/10
Pretty darn good for a classic style screenshot! Not sure what else to say, but nice job.

CastChaos - 7/10
Excellent detail for a screen of it's type. This is what you call a "complete shot".

Nuvo - 7/10
Pretty good. I like the idea of the beach, the ledges, and the shallow water. It's a very good usage of detail while at the same time acts as a typical overworld screen in function.

Oy, such a hard decision to make this time. I will go with Ebola this time because he took the biggest risk out of all of them.

[Professor Bedwetter]

Damn everyones is good this week


But I have to go for Evan. just keep pumping out those awsome screens!

[Nicholas Steel]

WtG wins hands down.

[Shoelace]

Evan the Great has won SotW this week. Congrats!

Send in your screens for SotW peeps. I am also going to submit a screen as it has been forever and a day.

[Mitchfork]

WtG wins hands down.

Willy the Great?

Congratulations Evan!