8 replies to this topic

[nicklegends]

Rastael
Cave of flames

Shane7227
A familiar Kakariko Village from my Link to the Ice Age project.

Doctor Potts
I like maps

We'll end this contest around May 31st. Good luck, everybody!
P.S. I will update the long-neglected Map of the Month leaderboards and archive within the hour.
Also note that Doctor Potts updated his map shortly after the contest started. The original is here.

[Demonlink]

Ok, my reviews so far:

 

Rastael: A very good use of the Cave of Flames set of Pure Remembrance. However, there is something I can't put my finger on, but still, a solid shot in my book.

 

Shane (Shane7227, not Charizard ): A great shot demonstrating ALTTP Kakariko. My vote went here, but the only "but" I have is that the shot lacks a bit of detail, although the palette (Grasslands) helps it. 

 

Doctor Potts: Great use of classic, but still, hmmmm, I see it's pretty much a basic one, but alas, how much detail can you get in classic? XD A few tile errors I see here and there, but meh, who cares?

[NoeL]

Voted for Rastael, but you need to do something about the ground-to-lava transitions.

[Shane]

I myself voted for Rastael too. But the mix of MC, LttP and GB does not go well. Don't tMC have graphics for the mine-cart stuff? Also surely there are several objects that can be replaced with stuff from the Minish Cap such as the sign, switches, chests, etc. I don't blame you if you refuse this lengthy task; but it will be a kick ass visual map for sure.

[Rastael]

thx for your feedback.

 

Yes, there are MC-rails in the tileset, but they don't go well with the rail-script.

[David]

I really liked Shane7227's map this week. I just love how the villages change appearance like that. Good job.

[Obderhode]

Rastael's is very nice and got my vote.

 

However, I am hoping that Shane's is a quest that will be completed. The Ice Age concept could be interesting!

Edited by Obderhode, 25 May 2014 - 03:48 PM.

[ZeldaPlayer]

I voted for Shane7227, his is great. Especially looking like the screens in the town in LTTP. Good job!

[nicklegends]

Rastael (23 votes [62.16%])
Shane7227 (13 votes [35.14%])
Doctor Potts (1 votes [2.70%])

Rastael wins Map of the Month 51! His Cave of Flames torched the competition. Congratulations.