1004 replies to this topic

[Fabbrizio]

You're banned because I feel like I currently have you stumped. So long as I'm saying my pony show is inferior to something, you can't disagree with me

[Russ]

You're banned because I'm not trying to disagree with you, nor have I ever been. I just said the pony show doesn't do it for me. You took that as a personal challenge.

[Fabbrizio]

You're banned because I won that personal challenge. The objective has always been to get people to TRY the show. Now, depending on what about the show made someone not enjoy it, I may ask that people watch a bit more, but it's not the case with everyone.

Take NoeL for example. He took the initiative to watch every episode (and I didn't even ask him to watch ONE episode so it's not like I kept pushing him to watch all of them), and at the end he admitted he thought Pinkie Pie was the best thing ever, and he still doesn't like the show. That's an opinion which leaves nothing to be desired.

TS watched four episodes and said he didn't like it, but that if he ABSOLUTELY HAD to pick a favorite character, it would be Fluttershy. That's an opinion which leaves a little bit to be desired since episode 7 will have any Fluttershy fan absolutely giddy, and so to not make it to that point is an absolute shame.

You watched only one episode (and that one episode was one of the three worst episodes in the entire series) and for your reasons for disliking it you cited all of the things which made episode 1 different from every other episode in the series. That's an opinion which leaves much to be desired.

< Is banned for turning You're Banned into the Debate Forum.

Edited by PowerGauntlets, 19 August 2011 - 09:55 PM.

[Russ]

OBJECTION!

You're banned because somehow, the word debate triggered the PW portion of my mind. But even with your argument, I dislike all the characters (save Spike, who was pretty cool actually), to the point where MASSIVE (and I mean on a scale greater than Simon's) character development would be needed to make me enjoy them.

[Fabbrizio]

You're banned because after episode 2, MLP is nothing BUT character development. The characters change drastically just from episode 1 to episode 2, and from there they just keep getting better. Twilight stops being b****y and starts being eccentric and nerdy. Applejack stops being all family this and family that and starts being more focused on hard work and business and all that good stuff. Rarity stops being prissy and starts being hilariously epic (after episode 19, there's really no other word for her). Pinkie Pie stays hyper, but starts being hyper in a totally different way that's actually kind of fitting. Rainbow Dash becomes more justified in her self confidence when you learn about her past. And Fluttershy...well, she stays shy, but that's kind of endearing, and also she starts having assertive moments, and we discover she's also really eccentric...about some WEIRD stuff, too....

Oh also Pinkie Pie has a pet aligator.

Edited by PowerGauntlets, 19 August 2011 - 10:02 PM.

[Russ]

You're banned because one of my favorite comic authors has a pet alligator. In real life. Your entire argument has just been invalidated.

[Fabbrizio]

You're banned because that only serves to make my argument stronger. People (ponies are people too!) who have pet alligators are automatically awesome.

[Russ]

You're banned because it just doesn't do much for me, since I've seen the real life version of a pet alligator. Pet gators in the fantasy world just no longer do it for me.

[Fabbrizio]

You're banned for...having past experience with fantasy world pet alligators? You're not particularly familiar with Gummy (Pinkie's pet alligator) so the fact that you know fantasy world alligators no longer do anything for you means you've had other experiences with them...

Please, do explain...

Edited by PowerGauntlets, 19 August 2011 - 10:25 PM.

[Russ]

I'm terribly sorry... I think I might have mixed up my own childhood with fantasy experiences. Dreadfully sorry... And you're banned...

[Fabbrizio]

You're banned because that means my argument is un-invalidated (double negative FTW) and we may proceed.

You're also banned because your Phoenix Wright comment a few posts back triggered me to get a new avatar.

Edited by PowerGauntlets, 19 August 2011 - 10:57 PM.

[Cukeman]

You're both banned because I miss Zelda

[Moon]

You're banned because I don't know why you miss Zelda, nothing happened.

[Fabbrizio]

*skips Yoshidude*

You're banned because there's no reason to miss what surrounds you every moment you post on this board. Just look at the effing logo.

Edited by PowerGauntlets, 19 August 2011 - 11:17 PM.

[Ventus]

Edit Ninjad
You are banned for Being A NINJA!!!

Edited by linktopower, 19 August 2011 - 11:19 PM.