50 replies to this topic

[Joe123]

^Lol, Joe! You sounded so newbieish... I also agree that the subscreen could be better, but I wouldn't mind if you kept it this way. And the hearts still own.

But I am a newbie!
Honest!

I'm still not changing it =P

I'm glad people like the hearts though.

[IaN]

It was a tough decision between CastChaos and Joe123, but in the end I went with Joe.

[Cobgoblin]

Well, third loss in a row for me, I guess I've just lost my edge, if I ever had one.

Majora: The trees on the ice look odd. It looks very much like super mario to me for some reason... probably the ice.

LostInHyrule: I like it... I don't know what else to say.

CastChaos: Well, the symmetry is to be expected as it is simply a building. What I like most is the event occurring in the shot.

Gray0x: When I first saw this, I thought it was a JPEG... but it seems as though you just put a sandstorm over it. Nice. I like how you managed to do the uncovered corner right.

Joe123: Overall, the shot is nice, the only thing I don't like is the epona sprite. Probably because it's a big sprite, and is harder to shade...

Nuvo: Mostly custom work here, it's basically just a prefab base that has been set up over several oil spots. Hence the cave walls, and the plant matter along the floor that's still there. If you see the rest of the base, you'll know that most of the base is pretty much on top of an underground lake. Too bad I couldn't explain that in the shot.

I voted for myself, I think I'm just getting desperate now.

Edited by Nuvo, 11 February 2008 - 05:39 PM.

[Plissken]

Voted for Nuvo, amazing interior work. Nothing you put out disappoints me.

[Majora]

Did it ever occur to anyone that the trees might be... FROZEN? Honestly, do people not try to connect things back to Zelda games? OoT namely. WHY was Zora's Domain frozen over? >_> Was it a "natural" freeze? >_<!

The trees grew THEN froze.

[16:59:13] <~MajoraDragon> Bleh, some of the comments on my shot in SotW are irritating.
[16:59:27] <~MajoraDragon> The constructive ones I welcome and encourage, but... >_<
[17:00:31] <~MajoraDragon> The trees are too flat <---- Good comment, could use some elaborating, but otherwise good comment.
[17:00:46] <~MajoraDragon> Nathaniel's is the "best"
[17:01:11] <~MajoraDragon> gray0x's I'll let slide because at least he points out the flaws and elaborates a tiny bit
[17:01:24] <~MajoraDragon> CC's....
[17:01:36] <~MajoraDragon> Makes no sense
[17:01:53] <~MajoraDragon> It's the (presumed) center of a lake... on an isle of ICE
[17:02:09] <~MajoraDragon> I hardly see why he expects a rainbow of colors there
[17:03:20] <~MajoraDragon> Nuvo's is sub-par because he failed to elaborate
[17:03:44] <~MajoraDragon> er
[17:03:48] <~MajoraDragon> NoeL's

(I confuse Nuvo and NoeL some times... I blame the fact that they both start with N's)

Yes, those lines may make me sound mad... and I am, but not solely at SotW (if at all), real-life stuff, etc.

Edited by Majora, 11 February 2008 - 06:08 PM.

[CastChaos]

Majora, so the trees grew out from water, which THEN froze? Just because trees grow from soil, but that ice doesn't look like frozen ground... rather like frozen water... which never ever seen any soil even from far away...

[Eddard McHorn Van-Schnuder]

Then really... who cares? Maybe there's an island UNDEr the ice?
Or... maybe it really have no particular reason... his game still rocks... and so does his screen.
And no, it's not the screendesign... I'm gonan be honest... it's not awesome in design... really.. but it gives a very special feel, that is just... ''woah''!

Edited by Migokalle, 12 February 2008 - 02:58 AM.

[ElLibertador]

Or maybe it's Zelda and it really shouldn't matter. Houses on clouds don't really make sense either, but that didn't stop Minish Cap. Why go for realism anyway? It's Zelda.

Edited by LinkMystro, 12 February 2008 - 07:03 PM.

[Russ]

Or maybe it's Zelda and it really shouldn't matter. Houses on clouds don't really make sense either, but that didn't stop Minish Cap. WHy go for realism anyway? It's Zelda.

About time somebody said that. So there is a tree growng out of ice. Big deal. You guys complain about that being unrealistic, and then go make quests where Link has to rescue a princess from a giant pig or a wind mage using a magic sword. It's Zelda! It's not supposed to be realistic!

[Eddard McHorn Van-Schnuder]

About time somebody said that. So there is a tree growng out of ice. Big deal. You guys complain about that being unrealistic, and then go make quests where Link has to rescue a princess from a giant pig or a wind mage using a magic sword. It's Zelda! It's not supposed to be realistic!

And then make that 3456 times...

[Plissken]

And then make that 3456 times...

A broad style? Why the hell not? If you make the game different but still unrealistic why in the world should that matter at all?

Edited by Plissken, 12 February 2008 - 05:42 PM.

[Joe123]

A broad style? Why the hell not? If you make the game different but still unrealistic why in the world should that matter at all?

I think he meant 'make a quest where Link has to rescue a princess from a giant pig or a wind mage using a magic sword' 3456 times.

3456 isn't a very imaginative number, all the digits are in a row. Hrm.

[Eddard McHorn Van-Schnuder]

Xd... that is actually just a coincidence!
But yeah... it's getting kinda old now... ''Meh... save her again!?''
You know...

[Majora]

In my quest you don't save some stupid girl who got kidnapped again. You save the world (and probably all the known universe) from an evil demonic Mask... OOPS, I SAID TOO MUCH :s

[Eddard McHorn Van-Schnuder]

In my quest you don't save some stupid girl who got kidnapped again. You save the world (and probably all the known universe) from an evil demonic Mask... OOPS, I SAID TOO MUCH :s

Hmm... I must say, I was kinda allready knowing that it HAD to do somthing with masks... seeing your name, that is :3