26 replies to this topic

[Alex-Link]

I voted for Twilight_Knight, almost voted for Furion but Twilight_Knight's has this cool Wind Waker vibe to it, nice job!

[Russ]

Twilight Knight: Perfect. *votes*

Furion: It's near perfect, but the cliffs are just too straight.

Kenster: It's an good screen, but doesn't really scream out SotW to me.

Edit: Shoot, I accidentally hit the null vote button. Can one of the mods change my vote to Twilight Knight?

Edited by Russ, 16 November 2009 - 10:40 AM.

[SpacemanDan]

Twilight_Knight: Solid and well-designed. It's got a nice balance, in my opinion, to it. Nicely done.

Furion: Looks great! It's a nice, fresh breath of life for the classic set, even though I'm not a big fan of classic updates. Very nicely done!

Kenster: Simple BS shot that's nice, but could use some detail. Also, I'd suggest covering the corners. Other than that, nice.

I can't seem to remember who I voted for, lol. Everyone did well this week, nicely done!

[Xiion]

Went with Furion, only partially influenced by seeing someone else use my tiles. Twilight's is good too, I like the variety in the ground detail. Kenster has a good base, a bit of detail to the water itself (not more rocks, I'm referring to texture) in addition to suggestions from previous comments, would make that screen really nice.

Yes. I ripped them from the great desert, recolored, and put them into a new tileset.

That wasn't a desert... those were clouds... it was a mountain top...
BTW: Did I include the tropical plants (2x2 palm tree/ 1x1 palm bush) I drew in that quest, I can't remember. If not, I'll post them somewhere.

[Christian]

Twilight_Knight gets my vote. BBDX is starting to look pretty good. Though i would suggest more detail and bigger trees

Furion - This shot reminds me of oracle of seasons a lot. Maybe some originality would have gotten my vote. Overall, is not a bad shot.

Kenstar - Not bad for a BS tileset. You're doing a pretty good job.

[Marco]

Went with Furion, only partially influenced by seeing someone else use my tiles. Twilight's is good too, I like the variety in the ground detail. Kenster has a good base, a bit of detail to the water itself (not more rocks, I'm referring to texture) in addition to suggestions from previous comments, would make that screen really nice.
That wasn't a desert... those were clouds... it was a mountain top...
BTW: Did I include the tropical plants (2x2 palm tree/ 1x1 palm bush) I drew in that quest, I can't remember. If not, I'll post them somewhere.

But...the quest title was actually, "the_greatdesert_quest" something to that view. I know it is mountains.

[Xiion]

But...the quest title was actually, "the_greatdesert_quest" something to that view. I know it is mountains.

Should be, zelda_arcade, or, 2.5 mini quest... great desert...

...ehh, whatever, its not that important.

[Kodan]

Twilight Knight, nice job, looks good!

[Harken]

I do believe I shall vote on Furion's. I like the sprites!

[Nathaniel]

It has been almost 2 weeks, and there are once again 0 screenshot entries for the next SotW. Once again, the once per week frequency depends entirely on there being participants. I mean, Angeal or Ebola could put one up right now, but who could you vote for, right? I don't know how much that can be stressed to get the message across, and nobody here should have to be in your faces about it. It should be a spontaneous reaction, as they would say in chemistry, but that isn't the case right now. You guys are giving those who run this more and more reasons to throw in the towel for good on SotW. Please don't encourage that. Are we nearing the end of this long standing event? It takes only three people in the short run at least have the opportunity to prove that wrong. Any takers? In the long run though, it will depend on more than just three people. Only time will tell, but that time isn't infinite either.

[Russ]

I'm submitting one right now. Hopefully this will help get SotW started.

[Mitchfork]

Twilight_Knight - 22 votes = [41.51%]
Furion - 29 votes = [54.72%]
Kenster - 2 votes = [3.77%]
Total Votes: 53

Furion

Bringing back the NES.

Twilight_Knight Furion cleans up this week. Congratulations to him!

Sorry for messing this up earliear, I don't know what I was thinking.