32 replies to this topic

[Plissken]

But that's also no excuse to be a really good screenshot. Just because MO is diffrent from the rest is no excuse either.

What?

Also, Plissken, I consider the things you said as opinions or taste, not as rules. The background makes it confusing? Good! An effect I want.

Well, when it gets cramped walking around it's annoying. That's just something that's...known, like covering your corners. Also, if I'm walking around and look up and see grass floating above my head next to a roof's edge I'd be weirded out. Now, maybe it might be cause I'm on a floating castle that's being supported by a cloud, but I'm assuming this isn't magical grass. It just makes it look more sloppy.

[Dawnlight]

It's an EXTREMELY tough call between Twilight_Knight and Molten Onyx, in the end I had to go with Molten Onyx. Those mountain and water tiles are fantastic.

[Bourkification]

I voted for Molten Onyx. Everything about this shot appealed to me. From the graphics, to the screen design, I just loved it.

Good show from everyone, keep it up guys!

[Lemon]

Molten: Nothing more than a re-assortment of PrinceMSC's brilliant work. Though the originals are still far better (in particular the dragon one. PrinceMSC's water remains to be the best I've ever seen). No vote for you.

Joe: Another GB shot. Yippie.

Twilight: DoR graphic with a creative, interesting twist and FF mountains in the background to simulate a floating isle. I'd recomend making the trees in the background a bit smaller, as they are currently as tall as the mountains, but besides that; the only creative shot, get's a vote.

[Bourkification]

Nothing more than a re-assortment of PrinceMSC's brilliant work.

What is to say that Joe123's is nothing than a re-assortment of Nintendo's work, or Twilight_Knight's is nothing more than a re-assortment of Radien's work?

Moltern's shot is just as original as the next person's shot is.

Oh, Joe and Twilight, sorry to use you guys as examples.

[Neppy]

I voted for Twilight's. I like the overall effect, and all. Good work. Great shots this week. Hard to choose from!

[Bayta]

Twilight gets my vote. I love everything about the shot. Very nice and realistic-looking. I love how it looks like the castle is floating in the sky. Very well-done.

[Russ]

Twilight Knight. His is just awesome. The other two are good too, but TK's just blew away the competition.

[Geoffrey]

Nothing more than a re-assortment of PrinceMSC's brilliant work.

jimmyb is right, if you use a tileset that someone else made, your simply doing a re-assortment of their tiles.

I'm not going to fight about it, it's all in what peoples tastes are. If you don't like my shot, it's cool, I don't mind, suggest how I could make it better.

Edited by Molten Onyx, 23 December 2008 - 01:30 PM.

[trudatman]

love it. voted 3.

[LostInHyru1e]

Voted for the WW0 shot. WW was my favorite game, and the tiles look good!

[SpacemanDan]

Joe123
A good, solid GB shot. Nothing that drew me right out, but still a good shot.

Twilight_Knight
This screen looks great! I like the colours and the detail. A great, original idea and screenie. Very well-done! *Vote*

Molton Onyx
A good shot that's designed well. I don't have any complaints here. Nicely done!

Great work everyone! It was tough to choose, honestly.

[Master Maniac]

I voted for twilight knight.

@Joe123: well built screen and nice fall colors, but it just didn't catch my attention

@Molten Onyx: (hope i spelled your name right) its a nice shot in a nice tileset, but it also looks like the shot you used as your default picture. if it didnt look like i'd seen it before, i might have voted for it.

@Twilight Knight: i like this screen. nothing really wrong with it, aside from the fact that the mountains underneath looks like a repeating pattern. that doesnt take away from this shot, however, because you very cleverly, and very well used the detail of that pallette and tileset. by the way,i dont think tree variety is any problem here, as you used multiple different colors of trees instead of just one. lots of detail and lots of pleasingly bright colors. you got my vote.

[Soarin]

I vote Null they all look good.

[Twilight Knight]

Twilight: DoR graphic with a creative, interesting twist and FF mountains in the background to simulate a floating isle. I'd recomend making the trees in the background a bit smaller, as they are currently as tall as the mountains, but besides that; the only creative shot, get's a vote.

Hmm, that's a rather good suggestion. I will do my best at this then.

Also, again thanks at everybody voting for me, you don't know how much I appreciate this!