17 replies to this topic

[Neppy]

Theryan

Long before the Superdome, where the Saints of football play.

Taco Chopper

"Link" leaves town only to "realise" he might need something to cut those "bushes" down...

Marco

Frostmint Candywood. We've been here before.

Jared

Have a Happy New Year! \o/

William

Happy Holidays, everyone! (Palette and tile edits were both made by me)

Alison

Merry Christmas

[Marco]

Theryan: I love this shot and the palette. The minimap title is delicious. 7/10

Taco Chopper: Southern Hemisphere holiday = hot. Therefore, I see the festivity. The open to unwakable ratio is just right. 6/10

Jared: This screen is the stereotype of holiday winter. I love it. It has a tree. A Christmas tree. No complaints. 6/10

William: Diggin' the graphics. Well rounded shot. Though, the palette could be more hued with gray. 7/10

Alison: Original, outside the box. 9/10

[Taco Chopper]

I nulled. Even if I wasn't in it I would have nulled anyway, there isn't really anything that catches my eye.

The open to unwakable ratio is just right.

Come again?

[Cukeman]

I voted for Theryan because it is really good landscape design, even though
the bushes look larger than the trees.

[Dawnlight]

I voted for Liam. I like your custom palette and edits.

[Adem]

Theryan: I like this one a lot! No complaints.

Taco Chopper: The design is decent, but I feel like it needs some sort of activity. Punch, pizazz, yahoo and how. Not a bad shot, though!

Jared: R U COPYIN ME FRUM LAST YRRR

All the Hylians down in Hyrule liked Christmas a lot. But Ganon, who lived just North of Hyrule, did not.

... ... Just kidding. I think there's a little too much white, and the ground detail gets lost because of it.

William: Not too shabby. My only complaint is the water. My eyes were drawn to it instead of the rest of the screen. Maybe if you made them a bit more subtle?

Alison: Happy New Year

I voted for Theryan.

[Geoffrey]

Alison gained my vote for irony.

[Theryan]

I nulled for obvious reasons.

Theryan: OMFG what are you doing you stupid idiot?

Taco Chopper: The bottom half of the screen looks a little too bare, especially around the edges. Also, the bottom left corner is open, which is a pet peeve of mine.

Marco: Solid screen design. One things that looks off to me is the top of the waterfall. It looks like it should be about half a combo lower.

Jared: Other than the tree in the middle, there really isn't much of anything going on. It's a nice picture, but as far as screens go, it's not all that well designed.

William: I like the design of this screen. The only error I can spot is that one of the trees is getting cut off by the mountain walls.

Alison: Solid GB screen. It looks a little bare, but I guess that's good given the environment.

If I had voted, I probably would have gone with William or Marco.

[nicklegends]

None of the shots really called to me, but I voted for Theryan for the color composition. I wasn't a fan of the GB slashable bushes, though.

[Koh]

Voted for Marco, his was definitely the "brightest" of the bunch. But they weren't bad at all. Though I do have some things to say on a couple:

Theryan: Anything non-Classic plopped into the Classic Tileset immediately becomes out of place, unless it is stylized to fit Classic's graphical style. That said, those GB bushes must DIE [/CDI Zelda Reference].

William: Custom tileset, eh? Reminds me of the Happy Set .

Alison: That boulder looks horrifically out of place. As if it's just floating above the lava, instead of actually in it forming a bridge. To remedy this, edit it so it appears as if it's submerged within the liquid. Of course, with the space you left open up there, Link could just shimmy around the gap altogether .

[Theryan]

I wasn't a fan of the GB slashable bushes, though.

That said, those GB bushes must DIE [/CDI Zelda Reference].

I know they look out of place, but I hate and have always hated the default bushes in classic. They look way too similar to the bush tree tiles. So I've been using the GB bushes until I can find something better.

[Jared]

I think you're using the Pure/DoR versions of the GB bush. The real GB/C bush is smaller. Why don't you rip that from EZGBZ?

[Theryan]

I think you're using the Pure/DoR versions of the GB bush. The real GB/C bush is smaller. Why don't you rip that from EZGBZ?

Jared. Take my internets. All of them. I never realized there were 2 different bushes in EZGB and Pure/DoR.

[Avaro]

Wow, marco, that looks great! Did you make this tileset? Yes, the top of the waterful could be one tile lower, but other than that I really like it. Voted for this screen.

The others are great too

[Neppy]

I went and voted for Marco this week. I love the screen. Neat palette and everything.