21 replies to this topic

[Mitchfork]

Avataro

Eeek! I hate spiders!

Master Maniac

Link: "So let me get this straight... The Fairy's gift was a portal to the woods?"

dragonsword


Moo2wo

[Dawnlight]

I voted for Moo2wo although I do admit that you kinda overdid yourself on the grassy ground.

Edited by Dawnlight, 24 August 2010 - 09:33 AM.

[judasrising]

I voted for Master Maniac this time

Edited by judasrising, 24 August 2010 - 10:08 AM.

[Avaro]

I like Moo2wo's screen. it's a great pallette and there are also gameboy tiles in this.

[Russ]

All were very good, but I ended up going with Avataro, because I like the idea he has going on there.

[Koh]

Moo2Woo obtained Koh's vote this time.

Avataro: It's a nice dungeon shot, but due to the instant transition of dark green to black, the shutters look totally out of place.

Master Maniac: A standard, well-detailed symmetrical screen. AVOID leaving the corners of the screen open. Try using trees, big rocks, or cliffs at the corners of overworld screens.

Dragonsword: A classic-ish dungeon. Where's the action here?

[Lune]

Voted for Avataro. The elements in the screenshot fit well with the dungeon theme.

[King Harkinian]

I voted Moo2wo. I like the way he mixed the gameboy tiles and and the DoR tiles. Then again, I think the ground tiles should be more varied. Too much grass.

[Evile]

Voted for Moo2wo, it was the only one I liked.

[Christian]

I voted for Moo2woo. I'm sick of forest temples already.

[Cameron]

I voted for Avataro. Moo2two's shot was also good, but something about Avataro's just stuck out more.

[Master Maniac]

Nulled of course. This is my first SotW submission if I remember correctly. Everyone looks great though ^^

I like Moo2woo the best, peronally. But I would have used some different Octorock graphics. That particular Octo looks too MC-ish for the screen

[Moo2wo]

I voted for Moo2wo although I do admit that you kinda overdid yourself on the grassy ground.

Thanks. I'll keep that in mind when I design my "field" screens.

I like Moo2wo's screen. it's a great pallette and there are also gameboy tiles in this.

There's actually a grand total of six unedited (well, edited to work with the ground, obviously) original Gameboy tiles in there. Almost everything else uses some kind of update. Oh, and thanks.

Moo2Woo obtained Koh's vote this time.

Thanks, very much.

I voted Moo2wo. I like the way he mixed the gameboy tiles and and the DoR tiles. Then again, I think the ground tiles should be more varied. Too much grass.

Look at my reply to Dawnlight's comment.

Voted for Moo2wo, it was the only one I liked.

Why thank you.

I voted for Moo2woo. I'm sick of forest temples already.

Thanks.

I like Moo2woo the best, peronally. But I would have used some different Octorock graphics. That particular Octo looks too MC-ish for the screen

I think I might darken the reds on it so it doesn't stick out to much. Or I might rip in the BS Octorock tiles.

Edited by Moo2wo, 24 August 2010 - 07:59 PM.

[Soarin]

I can't decide on this It is really good this time..

[eNJuR]

wow, i can see already i lost bad. But thats okay, i was just working on some custom classic tiles, and wanted to see how they looked.

Avataro:Aaaack!! kill the spiders!! I do no like spiders, but i do like them included in a quest, good job!

Master Maniac: as had been said before, put something (like more of that undergrowth, perhaps) in the corners. and yes, I understand how difficult it is to make a well designed field screen that doesnt end up looking like woods. But my second, bigger problem, is the mountains. I guess i'm really OCD with z3 perspective mountains (i really like them, and think everyone should at least try them), so i have to ask, what exactly are you trying to pull? it looks as though you wanted to avoid doing any height variation/modification/etc by placing a sign over it? dont get me wrong, i like the screen and its concept, though.

Moo2wo: my fingers are tired, so to you, simply: good job! i like it!