32 replies to this topic

[Teilyr]

My first week as head of this spot.. Let's roll.

ennonfenom

How am I suppose to get up there?

Bowser Blanchette

'Ah, so that's how it works,' Link says to himself.

Xavier

Our currently nameless hero spends some tile admiring a cloud.

Octorockoncrack

No caption provided.

[Moonbread]

Gotta vote for ya, Xav. Excellently constructed, smooth all around. Nice subscreen, too :o

[Evile]

It was between ennonfenom and Xavier, but in the end I chose ennon. Good luck everyone!

[Plissken]

ennonfenom: Great originality, the only problem is the sprite. Link just doesn't match it at all, but regardless *votes*

BB: Typical BS dungeon shot, not that much more to it.

Xavier: Love the subscreen but the trees kill it for me, I just hate those trees.

Octorockoncrack: Pretty good BS overworld shot, the only problem is the right side of the screen, 1/4 of a screen with one combo really kills the shot.

Edited by Plissken, 04 November 2007 - 12:27 PM.

[Teilyr]

Yeah, I'm not a huge fan of those trees either. I put them in as a place holder until I find some better ones.

[Old Inactive Member]

ennonfenom : a great shot but umm how dose Link get up there (bad joke) (tie 2nd)

Bowser Blanchette : great BS shot and a good puzzle (tie 2nd)

Xavier: great shot and where did you get those trees (1st)

Octorockoncrack: not bad but it's just a starned BS shot (4th)

[Evile]

Sharon Daniel made some edited tops for those trees and they look much better. Fund here.

[Teilyr]

Xavier: great shot and where did you get those trees (1st)

They're in the default DoR set. Thanks for the vote, btw.

Sharon Daniel made some edited tops for those trees and they look much better. Fund here.

The Mini Treetop? I've been meaning to add those. I'll do that now, actually.

[Nathaniel]

ennonfenom - 6/10
Nice background, as repetitive as much of it is. The tree in the foreground is a good choice, and the ground isn't half bad either. The tip of the branch of the tree shown to the left looks identical to the tree you see entirely. I wonder if you can have several varieties of that same type of tree so as to reduce some repetition. Then that could make for an amazing set of screens.

Bowser Blanchette - 4/10
Nothing special. While it is a success as a functioning screen, it doesn't take any big risks that strive to inspire the viewer.

Xavier - 6/10
A functioning and well put together overworld screen. Not the best in the biz, but worthy as part of an anticipated well made quest or project.

Octorockoncrack - 5/10
A functioning and decently put together overworld screen of its type, although more detail could be added to the grass and ground to spice it up more. I am also not a fan of the large usage of small trees being used as a forest wall, despite it being popular to the original Legend of Zelda. The usage of bushes, large trees, and stones help this shot get a rating up to 5 from me.


My tie breaking vote goes to Xavier as the most appealing of the screenshots for me.

[EnnonFenom]

ennonfenom - 6/10
Nice background, as repetitive as much of it is. The tree in the foreground is a good choice, and the ground isn't half bad either. The tip of the branch of the tree shown to the left looks identical to the tree you see entirely. I wonder if you can have several varieties of that same type of tree so as to reduce some repetition. Then that could make for an amazing set of screens.

those tile are rops from a game called "popful mail" and thats how they tiles are laid out, but I guess I can edit some and add some variety. That was something I had planned on doing but yet to do

ennonfenom: Great originality, the only problem is the sprite. Link just doesn't match it at all, but regardless *votes*

I am working on that problem as of now!

[The Satellite]

Xavier, I love your screen, I even talked about it in chat, saying that I loved it, but, ennonfenom came out of nowhere, posting this in his QPF in Beastly Forums, and, well, I like that one more. So, ennon gets my vote.

[Joe123]

After looking down the list, obviously Ennonfennom's stood out to start with, then I liked the look of Xaviers, but in the end I chose Octorockoncrack's, because I usually find myself intensly disliking BS screens, but I really quite like his one.

[NineLives]

I can't seee Xav's screen

[The Satellite]

I can't seee Xav's screen

Someone else said that in chat. So I uploaded it to my Photobucket in case nobody else can see it:

[Titanium Justice]

I voted for Eneonfenom his shot is just so wickedly cool,and Xaviers shot is my
second favorite.

great shot but umm how dose Link get up there

Well sidesrollers are ussualy made in 2.50 so link should have Rocs Cape

Edited by HeavyTitanium, 04 November 2007 - 03:08 PM.