40 replies to this topic

[Neppy]

demonlink14

A mysterious and fresh new looking Lost Woods entrance!

Sepulcher

"How did I get here? More importantly, how did I survive that fall?"

nicklegends

Link is lost in the desert.

Aslion

screen shot #teenlife #swaggy #2013 #livelovelearn #yolo

[nicklegends]

Well, I win the award for most yellow.

As for the others--I know I'm kind of a hypocrite because I didn't try to make a good shot this week, but none of them spoke to me. demonlink14's is a pretty typical forest shot with a solid palette, but the screen's design suffers with the odd nook up top and the awkward placement of the leftmost "whirlwind" tree. Sepulcher's is another pretty decent forest shot, but the stump and the bright rock in the corners of the screen are somewhat distracting and seem to be thrown in only to add detail--they don't complement the environment very well. Aslion, last but not least, has an attractive GB-style shot but with a cramped area toward the top of the screen. The enemy feels misplaced; I feel it would work better in larger rooms, assuming it acts the way I expect it to.

After some deliberation, I'll go ahead and vote for Aslion.

[Aslion]

voted for nicklegends it's perfect
the other 3 aint tryna bring anything new to the forest game

[Shane]

I voted for Sepulcher. Although the /\ mountain formation on the left is something that bugs me, it's well designed and that's all that matters for SotW in my books.

[The Satellite]

demonlink14 - This one is beautiful and instantly wowed me... except for one thing, when I looked closer. The shadows remove the grass detail, which is present in the areas the light hits. It was a slightly jarring contrast; fix that, then it's perfect.

Sepulcher - Voted here. It's the most well-designed, most appealing, and it jumped out to me just as much as demonlink's did, maybe a little more. Very pretty, though admittedly the palette's not perfect.

nicklegends - This is the most accurate ZC screen ever.

Aslion - No complaints here, looks great.

[Orithan]

Voted for Seplucher for superior screendesign over the others.

 hr[/hr]
Demonlink14: Heh, not bad. I do have a few problems with the shot, however. First, you have a tree, a bush and some of the forest brush being only one tile away from the edge of the left edge of the screen. Move them one tile to the right and you should be alright. My second complaint is how the transparent forest tops obscure the texture of the grass on the ground, which causes inconsistency between the grass in the covered and uncovered areas of the shot. It is still a good shot though. 7/10.

Sepulcher: This is actually pretty well designed, especially for its purpose in the quest. However, I didn't like how you tried to jam too many different details into the screen - the rock and the random patches of bare dirt look out of place and should be removed (in the rock's case, replace it with forest brush). 8/10.

Nicklegends: I see hardly any visible effort in the screendesign at all because there is literally nothing but Link and a cactus amidst a sea of sand. Put in more effort next time. 1/10.

Alison: Interesting, but your custom ground tiles suffers from too much detail compared to the rest of the tiles in the shot. The rest of the shot is not bad, though. 6/10.

Edited by Orin XD, 29 January 2013 - 04:22 AM.

[Shane]

I actually think the rock looks good there. Helps mixes up the colours and variety.

[Dawnlight]

I voted for nicklegends for A for effort of the week.


But for Screenshot of the Week, I voted for Sepulcher.

[Moosh]

demonlink14
It ain't the prettiest screenshot, but at least it's from a quest that appears to be making progress.
Sepulcher
This screen sure is a screen. I can't praise or hate it really.
nicklegends
This shot angers me. I cannot believe that somebody would have the gall to submit a joke shot to a contest as serious as Screenshot of the Week. Shame on you for having fun. Fun isn't allowed. I haven't had fun in 10 whole years. Check your privilege.
Aslion
#Ivotedforthis #amidoinitrite

[peteandwally]

I hope that's a singing cactus.

[Russ]

I hope that's a singing cactus.

If it is... can I change my vote?

In all seriousness, I voted for Alison. I really can't find any complaints with the screen at all. I came very close to Demonlink, which is all really amazing, but Alison just barely won out.

[Dawnlight]

I hope that's a singing cactus.

It could be something like this

or this

Edited by Dawnlight, 29 January 2013 - 12:48 PM.

[Moonbread]

Now following @Aslion #kingofswag

[Rastael]

demonlink14:
great shot! It's not that easy, to create a good forest-screen with the pure-tilesset, but you did it. ^^
9/10 *vote


Sepulcher
also a nice forest! Almost as good as the shot of demonlink.
8,5/10



nicklegends
Screens like that are ruining SotW. I know that this is a joke, but you already have 6 "joke"-votes...



Aslion
Nice GB-shot! I personally don't like 3-colour-picture, but yours is quit good.

6/10

[Moon]

Voted for nicklegends because his screenshot was most definitely better than all the rest.