12 replies to this topic

[Neppy]

Anthus

A fence, the bane of any hero's existence. Challenge fences, and more!

Jared

*Insert "Here Comes the Bride" here*

Dragonite

I PureZC has fetish for river with a bridge crossing it, what do they have for a river with a broken bridge?

[The Satellite]

Anthus - There's a lot of style clash here, honestly. It's clear many of these tiles don't belong here, and it just doesn't look very good as a result.

Jared - It's bright and hurts my eyes. Not really, in all actuality, it's greatly designed, but the colors are off and a bit bright. Something seems off about the slanted water bordering the grass at the top of the screen, too.

Dragonite - Voted here, even though many of your shots are already like this. I guess you're just good at it, and it is a nice screen, but you really oughta work on some variety.

[Lightwulf]

Anthus - Yeah, Classic Link looks out of place with all the other cool graphics; so do the mountain tiles and the Classic tree tiles.

Jared - It looks like a hybrid of billowy clouds and rock sitting on the ground (unless it's supposed to be snow). Other than that, I really liked this screen. *Voted here*

Dragonite - It's a decent screen. I don't have any problems with it.

[Moosh]

It's funny...I almost feel like I'm winning since I believe I helped work on that screen...Almost. I should have Dragonite submit all my shots for Screenshot of the Week from now on.

[peteandwally]

I'm a sucker for SD3 grass

[Shane]

I voted for Jared, it feels different from your usual DoR quest.

Anthus: The design is perfect in my opinion, but however, the tiles do clash. I don't know if it's your goal or not but I'm not too much of a fan of it, sorry.

Dragonite: Would have voted here but now that TS mentions it, all of your GB work kind of looks the same (not a bad thing, but it would be nice if you break your style for different areas and such).

[Anthus]

I just want to point out, that all of our shots have a very similar walkable/ unwalkable layout Especially the two that aren't mine with the rivers and all.

It is interesting to see my shot next to better palettes, cause it makes me see how bad it was. I have since darkened it, but the tile aesthetic remains, cause it is what I'm going for.

I didn't expect to win, but I didn't think I'd be in last either, on to the comments.

Jared:
This is a nice shot, with a good layout, but I think the cliff formation in the upper right looks a bit off, especially with it being so close to a stream. It just looks unnatural. Also, I think the grass is a bit bright (is this something like calling the kettle black?) I probably would have voted for this nonetheless.

Dragonite:
This is a good shot, but I don't really see anything super special about it either. I do like your subscreen though.

Anthus:
Dude you suck, have you ever heard of shading making sense obviously not you n00b gtfo.

Edited by Anthus, 16 November 2012 - 01:27 PM.

[Shane]

Shane? You mean Jared, right?

Edited by Shane, 16 November 2012 - 12:09 AM.

[Anthus]

Shane? You mean Jared, right?

Oops, fixed. Sorry about that.

[Moon]

Just as a quick post, my shot is not supposed to be super amazing, I just got a shot that I felt looked okay to get the contest going, I am perfectly aware it's not "Screenshot of The Week" material.

[Haylee]

Just as a quick post, my shot is not supposed to be super amazing, I just got a shot that I felt looked okay to get the contest going, I am perfectly aware it's not "Screenshot of The Week" material.

ANYTHING is Screenshot of the Week material, except maybe something with little detail(Like a certain quest I played recently.).

Edited by Zephyr_Eevee, 17 November 2012 - 07:43 PM.

[Moon]

ANYTHING is Screenshot of the Week material, except maybe something with little detail(Like a certain quest I played recently.).

Actually that is not true, unless a shot is shit bricks amazing chances are it won't do well in SoTW, it's sad but it's the truth.

Also, why blatantly say a quest you played recently had little detail? :/

[Neppy]

Anthus - 5 votes = 16.67%
Jared - 14 votes = 46.67%
Dragonite - 11 votes = 36.67%

Total Votes: 30

Jared

*Insert "Here Comes the Bride" here*