17 replies to this topic

[Mitchfork]

linktopower


Isdrakthül


Moo2wo

Welcome to the Lost Woods.

Ornlu

These bushes look nice.

[Taco Chopper]

first

I voted for Moo2wo because his shot's a standout from the rest. In my eyes, anyway.

[Sheik]

I think the same, Taco Chopper. As do 100% of the voters up until now :3

[Dawnlight]

I voted for Moo2wo. I love the colors of that palette, and the detailing is excellent overall.

[Ventus]

I voted Moo2ow to this week Great job .
And only reason i joined this week was to get things going.
So I'm suspecting not to get any votes
i kinda Slapped mine together to fast so it looks like crap .

Edited by linktopower, 12 September 2011 - 10:38 AM.

[judasrising]

I voted for Moo2wo this round nice screen and colours.

[Moosh]

linktopower
Woot! Classic shots FTW! As much as I love classic shots, I have to admit this one is subpar IMO...6/10
Isdrakthül
This shot feels very very empty despite the level of detail put into it. Also the doughnut mountain formation is rather odd. 7/10
Moo2wo
JESUS MAN! MY EYES! I can't see what's going on here, there's simply too much contrast. It would probably be a decent screen in another palette or with orange tall grass and shrubbery, but the palette you chose here just killed it. Also the tree overhang shadow has too many holes leading to EVEN MORE EYE RAPE. 6/10
Ornlu
This shot looks beautiful! I might even say it looks like it was taken right out of the Gameboy Zeldas. My one complaint is the tile error near the bottom. 8.5/10

Edit: Congrats in advance to Moo2wo for winning.

Edited by Pokemonmaster64, 12 September 2011 - 01:44 PM.

[Haylee]

linktopower - It looks nice but there are sand enemies in a water area which makes it look out of place. 3/5

Isdrakthül - The pallete makes it look kind of dull. 2/5

Moo2wo - The foresty swampish palletes make it look very weird. 3/5

Ornlu - Got my vote,reminds me of Hawaii even though i've never been there. 4/5

[Cukeman]

linktopower - I like the idea of water lanmolas, but .jpgs are worthless file types that should
be banished from our solar system.

Isdrakthül - I really like what you've started, but it doesn't feel like you have put everything
into your scene yet.

Moo2wo - I'm not really into canopy shots, though they do seem popular. The blue tree and
mushrooms seem foreign to the palette. Perhaps they should be purple like that bush.

Ornlu - I love the tiles, but if that cave is only an entrance I don't see how Link could get to this
screen unless it's the first screen in a quest. I don't think the trees should touch the water.
Most trees can't grow that far out on the beach. I'm also not sure about the bright green
mountain borders, but at the least you could have edited those tiles so that you don't have
square green corners jutting out into the brown.

I like Ornlu's shot best for the tiles, but there were some drawbacks as well. Nulled.

Edited by Cukeman, 12 September 2011 - 01:55 PM.

[Ventus]

linktopower - I like the idea of water lanmolas, but .jpgs are worthless file types that should
be banished from our solar system.

Well I knew i forgot somthing :-\
Oh well .jpgs are Are crappy for SSOTW
Should've Saved it as a .png

[Sheik]

Moo2wo
JESUS MAN! MY EYES! I can't see what's going on here, there's simply too much contrast. It would probably be a decent screen in another palette or with orange tall grass and shrubbery, but the palette you chose here just killed it. Also the tree overhang shadow has too many holes leading to EVEN MORE EYE RAPE. 6/10

I suggest you never try The Minish Cap, you might loose your eyesight.

[Jared]

LtP - I like the screen itself, but the enemies themselves just don't fit. Fiery enemies don't hang out around water! 7/10

Isdrakthul - I can safely say I don't like this one bit, besides the palette. i don't like the mountains (But that's just me) and they're too straight. It's too empty. It doesn't seem like The Dark World, with no enemies. 3/10

Moo2wo - Loving it! I love the structure and enemy choice. But, what happened with the light green you had before? 9/10

Ornlu - I like it. Perfect palette, and all. I just don't like the tile errors! 8/10

[Twilight Knight]

I kinda agree with Pokemonmaster64, but in a less offensive way.

So I voted for Ornlu.

Bit of a bad week, I think. Sorry.

[Geoffrey]

Thanks for the comments everybody. It's not like me to make tile errors, this is probably the second time one has been pointed out to me before (not that I haven't been critiqued. ). To those wondering, this was originally for the flopped dungeon contest which ZCRealm was hosting back when it was CasualZC, we were allowed a small entrance area separate from the dungeon and this is what I came up with. So this shot has to be at least a year or two old, it was mostly submitted because I read that SotW needed some more shots to get going this week. However, I am glad people like it, as it is one of my favourite GB shots which I've done.

Ornlu - Got my vote,reminds me of Hawaii even though i've never been there. 4/5

This post made my day.

[Marco]

Ornlu's work has caught my attention. It isn't perfect, I see a few errors. Yet, the trees, and vibrant colors attract me. Good stuff.