37 replies to this topic

[/M/]

LostInHyru1e


Migokalle

''Trubute to NoeL... One of the greatest artist to ever have set foot in PZC... Thanks for everything NoeL!''

billy ronald

"Link takes a vaction from saving Zelda i meen what can go wrong"

[Plissken]

LiH-Mountains in the top right are used wrong again, or else my vote would've been here.

Migo-Impressive graphics, but we've seen them a lot, and they're obviously supposed to be the "catch." Overall design is lacking, and a lot of perspective issues all over the place.

Billy Ronald-No comment, as I've already given all the advice I can to you on DoR design.

Nulled.

Edited by Plissken, 30 March 2008 - 02:09 PM.

[Dawnlight]

LiH - Still anoter mountain issue which prevents me from voting for you.
A-

Migo - Ah yes NoeL found his sucessor! :vote:
A

Billy - Too Dull, Mountain Design is Cheesey, Don't like that water, and very underdetailed.
D

[LostInHyru1e]

Okay... what the heck is wrong with the mountains!?! They all keep a consistent 2-tile height!!! What did I do wrong?

EH STELLA!!!!!!

[Plissken]

The outcropping in the top right is one tile to large, needs to end one tile sooner.

EDIT: I may be an idiot, let me check something out.

EDIT 2: No, you need to end that outcropping one tile sooner. Pic is coming.

Edited by Plissken, 30 March 2008 - 02:32 PM.

[CastChaos]

LostInHyru1e: Another perfect hit with GB graphics. This time: sweet GB winter! I see only one mountain error (upper right).

Migokalle: The most wondrous building served with a great tree, wrapped up in good design. Vote.
(Great that I decided against entering this week.)

Billy Ronald: What is that thing up and left? Just not snow? As for the screen, well, definitely empty, but at least now not completely missing. Some more trees (especially at the left side) would surely help. Also, the mountain is layered on the water, so there are no ripples.

Ah yes NoeL found his sucessor!

Putting together NoeL's graphics makes somebody his successor? I knew I should have submitted that regular screen that had two tiles from Prophecies. I would have won.

[Dawnlight]

In this area, the top mountain area has to have a 3-tile height becasue it's made up of one 2-tile height plus one extra.

Edited by TriMaster001, 30 March 2008 - 02:37 PM.

[ZebraStallion]

Voted for Billy Ronald. I'm just tired of seeing GB shots and I already saw the temple of time picture. And I have one question for Billy, why did you put snow on a beach? I know there is probably a snowy area right next to it but it doesn't make sense.

edit: fixed typo

Edited by ZebraStallion, 30 March 2008 - 02:41 PM.

[Moonbread]

Perspective Issues, Migo... I don't know how you can't see it. It looks like it's about to tip over.

I voted for Lost. Good shot.

[Plissken]

This would be your section: (Purified cause I don't have GB downloaded on this comp.)



This is the fix:



Just some pictures to go with TM001's description.

[Nathaniel]

LostInHyrule - 6/10
Good design and detail. Overall it is good, but not something to be completely moved over either.

Migokalle - 7/10
I love the facade and the nature that surrounds the building. The slash bushes look a tad bit awkward around everything else, but not too much. Very good overall. Yeah, I just noticed the perspective issue as well. Had to dock one for that, but the screen is still good enough for my vote.

billy ronald - 4/10
I see this screen and straight lines are the first thing I notice, which is not good when it comes to designing natural things with a more advanced tileset. The sanded area could use more detail in some way. There is more detailed water to find that goes better with the more detailed tiles throughout the rest of the screen. Solid blues just don't cut it for this set in regards to blending things in. I am not sure what you were doing with what looks like snow or ash at the top and the left. I simply don't get it.

[Titanium Justice]

I voted for Migokalle, his screenshot is pretty awesome.

[Old Inactive Member]

Voted for Billy Ronald. I'm just tired of seeing GB shots and I already saw the temple of time picture. And I have one question for Billy, why did you put snow on a beach? I know there is probably a snowy area right next to it but it doesn't make sense.

edit: fixed typo

Yes it is right next to a soey area if you looked arounf the quest you would see areas with snow next to it ten when yo go in that directen there should be ice snow yata yata yata

[Mitchfork]

Voted for LiH. Migokalle's is just a picture and Billy's has severe design problems. Really, none of the shots this week were spectacular.