30 replies to this topic

[link3505]

CastChaos

"A 4 screen big Steam Machina?! It must be full of Mega Man references..."

Linkus

The "no subscreen" habit broken, Linkus sends Link to a lush forest.

Moonwhisper

The Legend Continues... and we all thought The Adventure of Link would've ended it!

Sharon Daniel

100% custom tiles

The Satellite

Oh, must be a real secret cave, if Octoroks are the only thing guarding it. O_o

[Bowser Blanchette]

CastChaos for me! (Like the Repliforce logo!)

Edited by Bowser Blanchette, 09 July 2007 - 08:31 PM.

[Evile]

Linkus's is sweet. *votes*

[Cobgoblin]

Lets go with Linkus.

CastChaos: It's a really cool boss , close second for me.

Linkus: I was about to say "too dark" but then I realized how much that comment bugged me, and decided to look closer, the shot is really nice, and I must say it's one of the cooler things I've seen from you Linkus.

Moonwhisper: It's nice, the border trees are really weird though.

Sharon Daniel: Kinda bright and boxy wouldn't you say?

The Satellite: Really nice, LttP always looks nice with a normal sized Link.

[The Satellite]

Null'd.

- CastChaos -

Alot better than the shot from last week, but there's still some conflict, IMO. It looks good, but it doesn't have good depth in some places.

- Linkus -

REAL nice shot. Very nice shot. My only problem: shading is a little dark. Nice, though.

- Moonwhisper -

Very pretty. Puts what you can do with the Zero Quest set to (almost) its limits.

- Sharon Daniel -

Alot of it's nice. Ground is nice. Roof is nice. The houses, which seem to be the focus of the screen, lack depth, though.

- The Satellite -

U PH41L.

[Moonbread]

Null'd of course.

CastChaos: It looks interesting, and assuming it's a custom boss, that looks pretty sweet.

Linkus: Pretty freakin' sweet. The graphics are amazing, and the screen layout is done well.

Moonwhisper: I wish you'd hurry up and finish this quest

Sharon Daniel: A lot of nice custom tiles, though the houses are still out of proportion >_>

TS: A good classic shot. It certainly reminds me of ALttP. Can't put my finger on why it does, though >_<

[Bayta]

I like Moonwhisper's shot. It looks very good with the Zero Tileset. I like how he went for the "Classic" look. It works really well when you know how to do it correctly.

[DarkFlameWolf]

CastChaos: Still too cluttered and the design is boxy and has no real flow to it.

Linkus: It would have been awesome but its too dark. Yes this may be fine for in-game when things are moving and you are interacting with the environment, but not for a winning SOTW shot. It simply drowns out the picture.

Moonwhisper: Hard to get my hyped up over Classic. Even if it is modified.

Sharon Daniel: Looks weird and don't really like the style. Stale design, need to improve on many of the aspects.

Satellite: The only thing coming close to a decent shot this week. So my vote goes here.

[Evile]

SD: The fronts of your houses look to flat. I have no idea how you could fix it either.

CC: Still confusing, I hope it makes more sens in ZC.

Linkus: F****** nice. Shadows make some of the stuff look odd though, but I still voted for ya!

MW: Good shot. I'm not to fond of those trees though, good layout though.

TS: Basically just a perfect Lttp screen. Looks pretty tight.

[WindStrike]

You know I'm bored when I critique SotW two weeks in a row.

... and because I'm in a more uppy mood, I'm going strain away from my usual over-critiquing, which happens to be quite annoying to about half the people.

CastChaos - Oh the heck with the critique I was originally going to give; THAT SCREEN DESIGN IS AWESOME! More specifically the machine than anything else. Sure, a little too much contrast, but that just makes the screen catchy, eh? One thing that bothers me, although I know would be hard to fix, are those turbines at the top, which are completely out of perspective from the walls. And the lower walls are little on the dark side... but with that overly super-special-awesome machine on the sides... it just owns the few minor detailing issues.

Linkus - *ups brightness to see if it becomes more visible* No offense. Ok, I really can't tell the detailing from one thing to another thing under the darker shadows. It all seems blended together... and I mean that as if it's all one color pretty much. Also, a lot of the detailing in the upper portion seems kinda... repeated. I can't really tell since the shading kinda blocks it just a little too much. Ok, negative comments are now coming to an end, but I unfortunately just had to point out that it's hard to distinguish much under the dark shadows. But seriously... DEAR GOD THAT'S BEAUTIFUL! Both in the tileset and in the shadow transitions (and the fact that you used different depths of shading, which is cool). Though I may suggest some variation in the grass detailing - it may seem ok just because the shadow transitioning over it, but I noticed that's all pretty much the same. Sweet custom tiles (well, most of them, from what I can tell).
One more thing... your subscreen = pure pwnage. I have nothing more to add to such greatness.

Moonwhisper - Interesting... I do quite like it. One thing bothers me - the trees. When I can actually see their trunks, they look fine perspectively in comparison to the dead trees in the center. However... due to their shading, when I look those on the bottom, they just look completely different - more like above rather than from the sides. Granted, classic-style tilesets have limitations, but I think the ground could use extra variation rather than plain + some tall grass. It's still a very pleasant shot to look at. Kudos.

Sharon Daniel - The houses are fantabulous looking, though the one on the left looks odd, where the roofs are facing left and right. It just looks... odd. Nonetheless, pretty spiffy places. They work quite well with the FF style trees (which are definitely great customness). The water is also pretty sweet. Now... the absolute sheer contrast between that... and the ground... ... that's ruining the shot for me. It's not the rocky path tiles so much as that ridiculously bright grass. If it were darker, I wouldn't quite mind. Ooh... pretty flowers... ^_^

The Satellite - Fascinating... a perfectly fit LttP shot into ZC, which looks almost flawless. Simple indeed it tis... though I suppose I could suggest it can be a little more detailed... though that'd completely ruin its LttPness. Great job!


... design. All shots in this week had it, but the one that catches me most for it goes to my punned spell.
*Wind casts CHAOSDOKEN!!!*
Darn me and my ridiculously lame jokes! I should just stick with randomness and contain my lameness there...

[Sharon Daniel]

I guess I'm the only one who's fond of my grass colors.

[Freedom]

The Satellite, nice clean shot, gets my vote.

CastChaos, looks like your name implies, Chaos

Linkus, too dark, what ya hiding?

Moonwhisper, gotta lose that blue hue, ekk.

Sharon Daniel, graphics don't fit my style, but looks like a lot of good effort on your part, would be my second choice.

[NoeL]

Linkus FTW... the tiles aren't really anything new but the multi layered shadows are tops

Also, the roll function is intriguing.

EDIT: IT'S NOT TOO F'ING DARK!!!

Edited by NoeL, 09 July 2007 - 10:32 PM.

[Sharon Daniel]

IT'S NOT TOO F'ING DARK!!!

Yeah. I gots ta agree. It looks damn good.

[Red Phazon]

Linkus, the darkness creates a nice looking atmosphere. I want to play through that.