32 replies to this topic

[link3505]

CastChaos

"Ruins suit a ballad best!"

NoeL

You know that nursery rhyme about Peter Peter Pumpkin Eater? This is his brother's wife's house...

Revfan9

I've finished my beer. I'll make a house out of it!

Trimaster001

"Which passageway leads to the Triforce? There's a lot of them!"

I have to say, it's nice not having to remind you guys and starting SotW late everyweek, with only 3-4 screenshots each time. Looks like SotW might have regained it's previous attraction to everyone! I have happiness

[DarkFlameWolf]

was gonna vote Revfans, but then I saw NoeL's and I'm like: I got my vote!

[Sharon Daniel]

I voted for NoeL, like, duh.

[Dawnlight]

The NoeL Factor

The Good: Outstanding Balence of Mountains, Trees, and Water. Very Creative Design. Animated

The Bad: Shadows look pretty chunky, no Link

The Revfan9 Factor

The Good: Great Shadow Effects, That lovable grass, that big patch of flowers.

The Bad: Purple Flowers look weird, no Custom Link, I don't think Link can fit into that bottle .

The CastChaos Factor

The Good: Took advantage of the DOR Tileset

The Bad: Pretty Chuncky Ruins, Death Mountain?

The TriMaster001 Factor

The Good: Why on earth did I enter...

The Bad: because NoeL's shot kicks mine 1,000,000 miles away

The Winner is....

NoeL

Edited by Trimaster001, 17 June 2007 - 02:30 PM.

[Feenicks]

My thoughts on these...

CastChaos: Two different buildings. BAD! Also, where are the mountains? It says "Death Mountain" on the subscreen!


NoeL: Looks a bit cartoony, but... but... It's cool like that. My vote.


Revfan: What's with the water? Also, I would think that Link couldn't fit into that entrance of the bottle. And that Link doesn't fit. Nice trees and flowers though.


Trimaster: Pillars don't fit. Square room. Brown. Should have made a border around the subscreen. DQ'd. (Sorry)

[Evile]

NoeL's shot is the best. *votes*

[CastChaos]

I nulled.

Of course. If I enter, suddenly somebody submits a wondershot.

NoeL has great tiles and two outstanding things: the mushroom house and the water. Though, the shadowing looks strange on the roof of that house.

Revfan9 has good tiles (I really love that marble path) and that bottle house is just super. But what is that thing at the upper right corner under the shadows? If it's water (probably it is) then the shadows mess it up badly.

Trimaster shoved us a good dungeon gameplay scene. At least it's not underdetailed like some dungeon screens here in SotW.

Maybe if I submit a screen to every SotW, I will get a time when nobody submits wonderscreens. Or better: I should make one...

[Old Inactive Member]

Trimaster001 vote


Review
CastChaos

Not bad but it didn't stick out like Trimaster001


NoeL

I think you went too far with that house it looks out of perspetive


Revfan9

Good but it don't look right with those flowers


Trimaster001

Good DGN shot everything looks just right like a real one made by nintendo

So overall this week : Good

[Peteo]

All of them are good this week, especially NoeL's and Trimaster's screenies. ^_^

But man, you cannot find a bigger custom tile lover around Pure than me so I just... like, gotta vote for NoeL!

[Nathaniel]

This is definitely a very good week. I like all four of them. The worst part of it is having to choose, but I am brave enough not to null vote.

All four have very good design to them, so I can't complain about that at all, so that narrows the matter down to graphics. Clearly Revfan and NoeL have the more superior graphics and uniqueness to them, and I give a slight edge to NoeL on overall shot appeal.

[Dawnlight]

You know it's pretty strange that some people like my shots the second. Well maybe not the core graphics users .

[NoeL]

*nulls*

Wow... I was worried about Revfan's shot beating me this week...

My shots always look so dull next to the others I must be more subtly minded when it comes to colours...

[Mr. Pimpy]

I almost voted for revfan...
...but then I realised my cursor was over the wrong circle and quickly switched to NoeL...

[Joe123]

I was going to vote for Trimaster's, but I don't like that Link sprite at all.

I voted for Noel's.

Why is there green on the roof of the building in CastChaos's though it looks wrong.

[CastChaos]

Why is there green on the roof of the building in CastChaos's though it looks wrong.

If you can't make out the pictures, zoom into it.

Is there anybody else who can't see that these are ruins...?

Edited by CastChaos, 18 June 2007 - 11:21 AM.