Reviews
Zeratul
Posted 18 November 2005 - 08:07 PM
Hmmm, where to start...
Well, you used some classic tiles as shown in shot #2, but you edited Link's tiles? The inconsistency looks poor.
The custom tiles shown in shot #3 and #4 don't look very good in my opinion. No stars there.
As far as the terrain goes, some things (like the water edges for example) resemble those of the BS Tileset, except the palettes are horrible. There is no detail to the grass, or the dirt, and i'm not fond of the castle either. The entire tileset seems to be poorly colored rips. On the plus side, it looks organized on the combo page on shot #1.
Sadly, I don't give stars for pity. Try harder next time.
Well, you used some classic tiles as shown in shot #2, but you edited Link's tiles? The inconsistency looks poor.
The custom tiles shown in shot #3 and #4 don't look very good in my opinion. No stars there.
As far as the terrain goes, some things (like the water edges for example) resemble those of the BS Tileset, except the palettes are horrible. There is no detail to the grass, or the dirt, and i'm not fond of the castle either. The entire tileset seems to be poorly colored rips. On the plus side, it looks organized on the combo page on shot #1.
Sadly, I don't give stars for pity. Try harder next time.
Lemon
Posted 06 November 2005 - 12:59 PM
The only real good (new) tiles are the castle and some others... Im sorry but I cant give you any more than one. Also, you should credit the people who actually made this tileset, considering you basicaly just made one on their work, and credit polygon .... you lose the one star you had because you dident give credits out to anyone.
