Oh man, this is gonna be a tough competition. I really feel like the odd one out here XD
Joelmacool12 - Once again, you've managed to make another amazing screen using this tileset. I got no criticisms other than the fact that the screen seems a bit to cluttered up (though I can't say much, my one kind of is too )
FalsePower - Like I said from the last time I've seen this, I really like this screenshot. It seems really different from the usual fire dungeons many people make in their quests.
RedTribeLink - I love the neat touch of having a waterfall fall into the room from the ceiling. Kinds of detail like that really enhance the screen. Other than that, it looks pretty cool. I do notice that the tiles on the corners of the screen look kinda weird in comparison to the walls, almost as if it's another level you can walk on, though I doubt that's really what they're there for.
Eddy - Oracle of Ages again, -3/10 I am disappoint. (I guess I could also mention to not make any note of that time on the top right corner, it doesn't take 7 hours to get to that point, trust me lel)
If I didn't submit, I probably would've voted for FalsePower or Joelmacool, with RedTribeLink just slightly in 2nd. Great job to you three