11 replies to this topic

[LinktheMaster]

Theryan

That feel when you want a chest, but never learned how to swim...

demonlink14

Awesome preview of Hyrule Castle

Rambly

*~*

Scootaloo

Princess Hero

-----------

Public Service Announcement
Hey everyone! SotW 400 is coming up really soon. In fact, it's the SotW after the next one! So let's try to get a great showing for it.

[The Satellite]

Theryan - Solid shot, but if that coconut between the two tiles isn't a walkable tile, then it seems like it's in the way. Unless that's the point of the screen, and you're supposed to get the flippers before you can do anything, in which case, nice idea.

demonlink14 - Solid shot, though the color of the flames seems a bit off.

Rambly - Solid shot, no complaints at all, except for that coconut (I always thought it was a coconut anyway) near the bottom right, it seems too close to the walkable area. Unless of course you can walk over it, then it's no problem at all.

Scootaloo - Solid shot, only thing that really bugs me is the repetitive grass, unless of course that's how it normally works in the actual GB games; I've only played Link's Awakening and I don't remember how all the screens work.

Solid shots this week, everybody.

[Dawnlight]

Rambly wins my vote. Theryan a close second.

demonlink14 - If you ever watched Soul Eater. (<- Intended to be a joke) It's not 100% symmetrical, which is not a bad thing, but the tile placement is pretty cluttered and messy. I also see 3 known tile errors on that screen.

Scootaloo - You nailed the grass detail, but it does look pretty empty.

Edited by Dawnlight, 18 February 2013 - 10:56 PM.

[Theryan]

FACT: Theryan's screenshot uses only palm trees.
FACT: Rambly's screenshot uses only palm trees.

FACT: Theryan's screenshot features palm trees on those forest ledge things that usually don't have palm trees on them.
FACT: Rambly's screenshot features palm trees on those forest ledge things that usually don't have palm trees on them.

FACT: The Satellite commented on a coconut combo causing walkability issues in Theryan's screenshot.
FACT: The Satellite commented on a coconut combo causing walkability issues in Rambly's screenshot.

QUESTION: Have you ever seen Rambly and Theryan in the same room at the same time? Coincidence? I think not.

I just figured I'd point that out... anyway:
demonlink14 - It's a nice shot. Nothing too spectacular about it though.
Rambly - No complaints here, solid shot.
Scootaloo - This reminds me a lot of GB. The only issues I have are the open corners and the fully grown tree in the middle of that dirt pathway.

I nulled for obvious reasons.

[Scootaloo]

Theryan and Rambly both disqualified for being the same person. Or uh, I guess scratch the both.

Nulled, of course. (Also I just don't have an issue with open corners all the time) :<

[nicklegends]

Theryan
Pretty solid all in all, but I'm not a big fan of the random details like the shell, wood fragments, and sprouts.

demonlink14
Not much to complain about, but nothing special either. The perspective on the torches is a little odd when they'e placed so close to the south wall.

Rambly
Vote goes here. Good mellow colors and subtle but effective detail does me in.

Scootaloo
Not much to write home about. Nice open design, but the detailed grass makes the screen look oddly dirty.

[Shoelace]

I voted for Theryan this week. It was really close to Rambly as I love the palette. However, the trees in the water look a little odd.

This was a great week. Good job everyone!

[Tree]

Voted for Theryan, not only for excellent screen design, but also for them treasure chest feels. Damn, I wanna cry for Link's troubling predicament

[Moosh]

Rambly's shot has trees in the water. I did not notice Rambly's shot had trees in the water. Rambly's shot is made of win.

TENOUTTATEN!

Edited by Moosh, 20 February 2013 - 10:37 AM.

[trudatman]

I like them all. still looking for the supposed errors in the castle shot. perspective SNAFUs are all I see. great stuff, kids.

[adsfndsajgfkhdjgkejf]

FACT: Theryan's screenshot uses only palm trees.
FACT: Rambly's screenshot uses only palm trees.

FACT: Theryan's screenshot features palm trees on those forest ledge things that usually don't have palm trees on them.
FACT: Rambly's screenshot features palm trees on those forest ledge things that usually don't have palm trees on them.

FACT: The Satellite commented on a coconut combo causing walkability issues in Theryan's screenshot.
FACT: The Satellite commented on a coconut combo causing walkability issues in Rambly's screenshot.

QUESTION: Have you ever seen Rambly and Theryan in the same room at the same time? Coincidence? I think not.

I just figured I'd point that out... anyway:
Theryan - No complaints here, solid shot.
demonlink14 - It's a nice shot. Nothing too spectacular about it though.
Scootaloo - This reminds me a lot of GB. The only issues I have are the open corners and the fully grown tree in the middle of that dirt pathway.

I nulled for obvious reasons.

(In all seriousness: I'm really surprised I got as many votes as I did and that the reaction to my screenshot was as positive as it has been considering I threw it together specifically so that SotW would have enough entries to start. Thanks, everyone!)

[Neptune]

Theryan - 22 votes = 59.46%
demonlink14 - 1 vote = 2.70%
Rambly - 12 votes = 32.43%
Scootaloo - 2 votes = 5.41%

Total Votes: 37

Theryan

That feel when you want a chest, but never learned how to swim...