12 replies to this topic

[Neppy]

green-kirby

South-east slashing is just one of those amazing things few heroes learn, the sword beam is another.

Nolornbon

While exploring a desert canyon, Link finds this ancient structure that looks like it was once a wet place. Evidence of animal sacrifice is present...

Ventus

Heading though the Moblin forest after a downpour, *Takes a big whiff* the fresh scent of forest.

Dragonite


Jared

Random sword on the ground...for the win!

trudatman

224x256 is so small... zoom in.

[nicklegends]

I vote for Dragonite. The design of the screen seems to complement the colors well because you get the green of the grass, the yellow of the sand, and the blue of the water. I don't really like how the waterfall ends abruptly in a pool--I'd expect some sort of river flowing from it, but that's my only real concern. Honorable mention to green-kirby.

[judasrising]

Nolornbon`s screen looks interesting , so my vote goes to that screen.

[trudatman]

I voted for Jared's, despite the weird V's on the roof and the strange brightness of the character and item sprites, because, overall, it has the best screen design. all of this week's entries are not quite up to par, to me -- mine included, obviously. my second pick would be Nolonrbon's, because it doesn't have color failures and it looks interesting (especially given the hint to peep sacrificial evidences) in its concept. however, it is also kind of plain in its symmetry and its tileset. plus, I think the bottom edge of the mountain pushing the player offscreen is unnecessary. anyway, it was a close call, for me, between those two.

[Jared]

I voted for Jared's, despite the weird V's on the roof and the strange brightness of the character and item sprites, because, overall, it has the best screen design. all of this week's entries are not quite up to par, to me -- mine included, obviously. my second pick would be Nolonrbon's, because it doesn't have color failures and it looks interesting (especially given the hint to peep sacrificial evidences) in its concept. however, it is also kind of plain in its symmetry and its tileset. plus, I think the bottom edge of the mountain pushing the player offscreen is unnecessary. anyway, it was a close call, for me, between those two.

Ah, that's rain. Thank you for the comments!

[trudatman]

so the rain streaks (the top right to bottom left diagonals) hitting the roof makes the V's? they only appear on the one roof and not the other? do you choose where they can appear? I zoomed way in to try to figure it out....

[Jared]

Yeah, I choose. Trying to keep myself organized however, I'm only using one rain screen, for the layer. it's not really something that will be looked at closely in gameplay.

[Orithan]

I voted for Ventus, soley because it wasn't seen in the Screenshot Critique Thread unlike Jared's and Dragonite's shots, my other picks. Tough choice this week.
Honestly, I have a small issue with shots that have already been shown in the critique thread. For me, they seem uninteresting because I've already seen them, especially if they were shown the day before the contest.
P.S. I did the same once, but that shot was revealed in the critique thread months (or prehaps even a year) before I submitted it into the contest. It would have been more interesting than shots unveiled right before the contest but less interesting than a new shot right off the block.

I voted for Jared's, despite the weird V's on the roof and the strange brightness of the character and item sprites, because, overall, it has the best screen design. all of this week's entries are not quite up to par, to me -- mine included, obviously.

It's not like that he can change the colours on the sprites, since you can't edit any of the sprite CSets on a DMap basis. I hate to say this, but unless you can find a way to make a nighttime pallet that also darkens all of the sprite CSets (5-11, 0-1), just deal with it.

Edited by Orin XD, 09 July 2012 - 03:34 PM.

[Octorockoncrack]

Voted for Ventus this week. I'm really liking those dark forest colors

[trudatman]

the way to "deal with it" is to mute the colors a bit, so they work in bright and dull environs. you excuse would make sense if the palette straight up were not editable, but they are. I understand why they would be on the brighter side of perfect for dark parts of a quest, but they could be dampened, especially if the shot isn't of a quest but is just a shot for the sake of a screenshot. I'm not saying that any of that applies, just that the wicked bright (MA, USA, what?) sprites in a dark scene degrade my personal enjoyment of a shot. immersion is key, for me. I did vote for that one.

Edited by trudatman, 09 July 2012 - 05:20 PM.

[Hergiswi]

green-kirby: You've got my vote. This looks like an authentic GBC shot and the palette compliments the screen very well.

Nolornbon: There's nothing wrong with this screen; it's designed very nicely. However, there just isn't anything too interesting going on.

Ventus: I always love your classic shots and this one is no exception. The shadow overhang, however, looks slightly too jagged to me. It almost seems unnatural.

Dragonite: This is another great GBC shot, and I must say I'm jealous of how well you use the GBC mountains. I don't like the subscreen font, but that's just personal preference.

Jared: I like this shot, though it slightly looks like there's a house on top of a house. The contrasting brightness (wicked bright, if I may quote trudatman) is also slightly off-putting.

trudatman: It's always refreshing to see custom tilesets. It's simple, but I like it.

[Einsiety]

Nolornbon got my vote, I have not seen the the revenge 2 tileset in a LONG time.

[Neppy]

green-kirby - 4 votes = 9.09%
Nolornbon - 7 = 15.91%
Ventus - 8 = 18.18%
Dragonite - 19 = 43.18%
Jared - 4 = 9.09%
trudatman - 2 = 4.55%

Total Votes: 44

Dragonite


Congrats Dragonite. Well done!