27 replies to this topic

[Mitchfork]

Chris Miller

What manner of enemy hath no face.?

Pabru

Enter the Forest of Nightmares

Pokemonmaster64

What manner of madness is this!?

King Harkinian

Dungeon shots. I think they are my strong point in screen design.

[Jared]

YOU MEAN I FORGOT TO ENTER?!
*cry cry*

Chris Miller - I feel like this can't even be counted for. Sorry. 0/10

Pabru - I like the design, but the palette is...very weird...7/10

Pokemonmaster - AMAZING. 8/10

King Harkinian - Best screen of the week. Nice design. very different. Could you PM me on how to make those kinds of puzzles, too? I never knew how

Voted for KH Good job.

[Dawnlight]

Despite the overly purpleish palette, Pabru's shot still wins my vote for its overall design.

[Moosh]

Oh well. Gimmicks won't win me this one...inb4 pabru wins by a landslide.

[Cukeman]

Chris Miller: Looks like you are going for a dark dungeon, but even so the palette could be
more varied - especially in the walls. And the design is very plain.

Pabru: The palette is perfect for a nightmare. I like the figure Link is walking towards
(Final Fantasy right?) and it's a good design, plenty of growth that makes it feel like a
real forest, I just have a pet peeve about having to walk under canopies to get to the
next screen. It feels like stumbling around trying to find what is walkable.

Pokemonmaster64: I guess you had to bring these tiles into Zelda Classic, but aside from
putting Link in the shot, there isn't really any part of this design that you are responsible for.

King Harkinian: I don't care for the palette, but the screen is interesting.

EDIT: Voted for Pabru, even though I love the GBC tileset, the walls in the lower right
corner don't look right; why does the wall fold back around, when there is no room to go between
the walls? Doesn't make sense.

Edited by Cukeman, 10 August 2011 - 12:00 PM.

[Adem]

I feel like Screenshot of the Year is just going to be all Pabru. Voted for him. I actually kind of like the palette.

[Russ]

Pabru wins this round for all around amazing design. Harkinian's a close runner up, but it lacks a certain feel that Pabru's has.

[Christian]

Pabru FTW!

[The Satellite]

Chris Miller - It's... empty. There's really not much to say here. It's got a good shape, but there's not much to it. Even an official game would have more to it than this. Some kind of detail, rubble, something.

Pabru - Excellent shot. Very well done, and the palette gives it an almost ambient feel to it. Kinda eerie, yet provoking. And the design is excellent. The only issue I can see is there's a bush on the left side of the screen, right at the edge. This is a no-no. Otherwise, this got my vote.

Pokemonmaster64 - You copied the World 1 Map of Super Mario Bros. 3 exactly and stuck Link in it. There's nothing original about this, because it's not your work.

King Harkinian - This is a pretty good dungeon shot. I like. Looks like a very good puzzle comes into play here, as well. Close second place shot. Well done.

[Orithan]

Voted for Pabru. None of the rest appealed to me much.

Chris Miller: This isn't worthy of SotW. Some tiles are used in wrong Csets and it's empty. Add plenty of floor decorations and at least add in a border. 2/10.

Pabru: The best of the lot by far. It suits the atmosphere perfectly. One problem with this is how the transparent overhang cuts off near the right edge of the screen. 9/10.

Pokemonmaster: This isn't your work. This doesn't even look like a Zquest shot. This can easilly be accomplished by taking the snapshot of the screen, with the sprite layer off and then pasting the Link tiles in an image editing program. 0/10.

King Harkinian: Easilly the second best here, looks very much how a Nintendo screen would look like. I can't see any flaws, but it doesn't appeal to me very much. 6/10.

[Moosh]

Pokemonmaster: This isn't your work. This doesn't even look like a Zquest shot. This can easilly be accomplished by taking the snapshot of the screen, with the sprite layer off and then pasting the Link tiles in an image editing program. 0/10.

I'm perfectly fine with people saying that it's no good because it isn't my work. I'm not fine with people claiming that I didn't make the screen legitimately. I can assure you that I did rip all the tiles in and if you want to continue doubting me, I can send you the quest file. I'd also like to point out that if you look at the actual map, you can see that the colors are different because I used Zelda 1's palette. You're free to hate on the screen, but don't try to deny the effort I made to create it.

In fact, anyone else wants proof? Here's your proof: http://www.mediafire...pspyjto01lkckom

Edited by Pokemonmaster64, 08 August 2011 - 02:57 AM.

[NoeL]

Voted Pabru. The palette is way too monotone, but there wasn't much competition this week

[Rover]

I voted for Pabru, I guess I'll give a little review or whatever

Chris Miller your screen is a basic freeform dungeon screen, not too much to say about it. It doesn't exactly "catch the eye" in this one

King Harkinian that's really good. It's a close second.

Pokemonmaster64, although you said that "but don't try to deny the effort I made to create it." I don't really see the effort. I've ripped Ninja Gaiden sprites before and entered them in SoTW but then I realized that was a big mistake, it took like 10 minutes but that's really not effort. It's just the SMB3 map which has been previously designed before in a game that you're trying to use with a Link sprite over it,

[Moosh]

Went with a gimmick/nostalgia shot. Wasn't be the first, won't be the last. I put about as much time putting my screen for this week together as I have for any other week. Maybe I just don't put enough effort into stuff...

[Nathaniel]

Chris Miller - C+
I have nothing against purple at all. In fact, I love how it gives that atmosphere a nice spook factor. I love the subscreen portion, which certainly reminds me of your Lands of Serenity Quest. However, the screen design is okay, as there isn't that much detail.

Pabru - A
What are the odds of getting two purple screens? It certainly does give a nice means of comparison of where one can go with that. I am really liking the overall screen design on this one, and proves you can do a lot with something that is conceptually so simple. Gives a night-like feel, with perhaps some emphasis on twilight without seeing it directly. Easy vote for me this time.

Pokemonmaster64 - D
I like remakes of screens from other NES games, especially from among my favorite games, but I have to admit that I think it is far from ideal for SotW. Almost all of the work was in finding all the graphics you needed and putting together something that was already made before, but just in a different program. So I can't give much, because there really isn't much creativity in making such a screen. Kudos on being able to do it, though.

King Harkinian - B+
For GBC graphics, I think this was well put together. It's a very functional screen, and does well with elevations. However, the palette is just a bit over the top for my tastes, as you can tell the very dramatic nature of the reds, blues, and yellows.

Oh, and...

Chris Miller - I feel like this can't even be counted for. Sorry. 0/10

Harsh, man. Harsh. Gonna have to disagree with you on this one. Personally, I would only give 0 (if I still rated that way) if somebody submitted a blank screen or was very clearly attempting to troll the event (which is certainly not the case here). The effort is still there in making the screen, but it just isn't an interesting screen due to not that much detail, so he at least deserves a little bit of credit. After all, he did give the room some shape.