Lord Settra - 5/10
The screen is pretty safe. There isn't much of a risk here, so I don't see the passion in this one. Most of the grass is still a solid green, so there is potential there for lightly scattering more details being worth a shot.
Phoenix - 8/10
See how just a little more effort and self assessment can make the grass look significantly better.

The screen is well put together, and is the caliber of design I would expect to see regularly in any four or five star quest. The color choices are tastefully done. Not boring, yet not off the wall either.
jimmyb - 7/10
Great choice of graphics, and pretty good usage of them from the looks of it. I am not a fan of the overlapping on the right side of the subscreen though. Looks kind of messy to me.
Mr. Mister - 8/10
As different as it is, I echo the same kind of words I gave for Phoenix's screenshot for this one. Good leaf shadowing too.
A tough decision, but I went with Phoenix, as it has a slighty better appeal for me.