15 replies to this topic

[Shoelace]

EnnonFenom


Molten Onyx

The shore of Great Rupea, or something like that.

T. Platinum

The hero returns home only to find death and despair...

[Marco]

. Molten. He has the best screen, even though it should have a small bit more of detail.
. Ennon- You get second. I said before, its to bright and....happy for me.
. Planti- I like the tiles, but its pure. Pure has the ani christ colors of ZC. Still, very good try.

Edited by Furion, 25 January 2009 - 11:05 PM.

[Dawnlight]

I'm voting for Molten Onyx. He has the best quality shot out of the three.

EnnonFenom - Everything in that shot is great except the color quality of your SD3 grass. I say make it brighter. It's a bit too dark.

T. Platnium - Try adding detail such as windows to your walls as well as detaling your floors. Also, try not to style clash. Make sure the tiles you use stay with the theme of your tiles so that they balance and flow together. (Your theme is mostly ALTTP houses)

. Planti- I like the tiles, but its pure. Pure has the ani christ colors of ZC. Still, very goof try.

Unless if you know how to work with those colors.

Edited by Dawnlight, 25 January 2009 - 09:25 PM.

[Nathaniel]

EnnonFenom - 7/10
Graphics are indeed interesting, although a little confusing with the lack of contrast the trees and other foliage have with the ground. The leaves of the tree in the lower right looks out of place with the rest of the screen. As for screen design though, I think it is very good.

Molten Onyx - 7/10
Very nice graphics, especially the water. Screen design is good, but not spectacular.

T. Platinum - 6/10
It's definitely good, but nothing really catches my interest. Looks like a good run of the mill screen for any quest with those graphics, but it doesn't have that luster I would expect from the best in SotW.

Tough call, but I ultimately went with Ennonfenom, as I think that one looks like the biggest effort.

[Russ]

MO. Ennonfenom's blurs together too much, making it hard to see. And T. Platinum's just doesn't scream out "SotW".

[Geoffrey]

My shot's been updated a bit since I submitted it.

EnnonFenom: You hafta' get ridda' that SD3 grass and find something that suites it better because those tiles are awesomesexycoolgoodexcellentgreatinsane but the grass doesn't work with it.

T: There's not really anything special about the shot, put some more crap (not real crap) on the walls though.

I know, I make no sense when I speak.

[Evile]

Going with Onyx on this one. The tiles are really nice and the layout is pleasing to look at. It could use a better palette but its still the best imo.

Ennon's is too bright and I don't really like the tiles.

T. Platinum is a pretty typical pure shot. Not terrible, just not sotw winner worthy.

[Christian]

I'm nulling.
Nothing interesting this week.

[Titanium Justice]

I voted for EnnonFenom. I'd love to see something like that made into a quest or a tileset!

[EnnonFenom]

EnnonFenom: Humm, Me thinks you suck at ripping graphics, your shot is DQ'D

Molty: Your shot looks like the same stuff you have been showing for a while, Its not bad, and its put together well.

T. Platinum: What can I say, its to linear. To me its just not a sotw material

I voted for EnnonFenom. I'd love to see something like that made into a quest or a tileset!

I planned on it I just got to find more graphics to add to the tileset. But they got to be similar to the ones from: summon night sword craft story 2

Edited by EnnonFenom, 26 January 2009 - 07:46 PM.

[hinsburg]

EnnonFenom: Whoa, sweet tileset. I love how the grass moves in the shot.

Molten Onyx: Fun palette, nice layout.

T. Platinum: Grr... That's a jpeg isn't it? That and it's kind of bland.

Ennon wins my vote.

[Professor Bedwetter]

Molten onyx, Stop doing really good shot, thank you.

*votes for Onyx*

[SpacemanDan]

EnnonFenom: I love the colours in this shot. They're so bright and lively, and really pop-out at me.*Vote*

Molten Onyx: I like this screen a lot. The design is very good, and everything is done well. No complaints about this shot.

T. Platinum: A good shot that outlines the idea that you were going for, but it seems a little too square. My suggestion would be to kinda change the room a bit so that it isn't perfectly square. (Maybe indent the corners inward or something?) Also, maybe a border around the room would work?

Great work everyone! The shots are very good this week!

[Bonegolem]

EnnonFenom. It's something fresh and colorful. Or the other two choices just weren't my cup of tea. The killing/massacre screen looks cheap, sorry.

[Joe123]

Molten Onyx it is.
EnnonFennom's grass just doesn't cut it.

I think MO's might benefit from a palette swap to make it a bit brighter, however.