25 replies to this topic

[Koh]

Sir Russ I obtained my vote through the joust this round!

Edited by Koh, 24 November 2010 - 11:52 AM.

[Adem]

Voted for OoTFan. The other shots aren't bad, but I like his the best. There's a few tile placements that bug me, but it's nothing major.

[Geoffrey]

I voted for OoTFan, he made a great dungeon screen, something that's hard to come by.

Russ, yours is very empty feeling. Add some bushes or something.

Yoshidude, yours is empty + angular. Not a good combination. Add bushes, because repetition of a single combo like that grass texture still leaves a very empty feeling screen.

EDIT@Russ, it looks like he could just walk around the right side of the tree to get it, but maybe that's just an illusion?

Edited by Molten Onyx, 27 November 2010 - 01:36 PM.

[William]

OOTFan: It's a nice little shot, I like it. 6/10

Russ: A nice job, I think it looks the most appealing to the eyes. 7/10

Yoshidude: Eh, I'm sorry man. It's not a "terrible" shot, and it is a perfect screen for a quest. But Screen Shot of the Week? I don't think so. Make a really good screen, take some time. Don't enter with your first screen, try to perfect a screen before you enter. Just a hint of advice, when I first saw SotW I entered no-matter what my screens looked like, so I know where you're coming from. Just try to make a shot with more "wow" factor. 3/10

But anyway, good job Russ, your screen earned my vote.

[Shane]

Yoshidude: Eh, I'm sorry man. It's not a "terrible" shot, and it is a perfect screen for a quest. But Screen Shot of the Week? I don't think so. Make a really good screen, take some time. Don't enter with your first screen, try to perfect a screen before you enter. Just a hint of advice, when I first saw SotW I entered no-matter what my screens looked like, so I know where you're coming from. Just try to make a shot with more "wow" factor. 3/10

I think it deserves 5/10 because I seen the first version its a better improvement trust me.

[William]

I think it deserves 5/10 because I seen the first version its a better improvement trust me.

I'm sorry man, I'm rating the version of the screen that has been put up for SotW, it isn't good. I believe that Yoshidude can improve, and I would like to see his other screen.

[Shane]

through I intend to agree I seen alot more from him.

[Jenny]

this weeks winner is OOTfan!

[William]

So it would seem. Do new SotW start every Sunday? I can't remember. I sent in a shot, however.

[Titanium Justice]

I voted for Russ. I like the autumn setup, looks nice.

[Mitchfork]

OOTFan - 18 votes = [51.43%]
Russ - 14 votes = [40.00%]
Yoshidude - 3 votes = [8.57%]
Total Votes: 35


OOTFan

"Venture with me into the unknown."

Congrats OOTFan!