16 replies to this topic

[Mitchfork]

Koh

Did Koh really just enter his SR entry here too? Either way, that beach is still dangerous.

William

Even Link stares with wonder at the image-quality of William's first non-JPEG screenshot.

Lynker

That must have been a huge tree...

[Zeldaman23]

Vote Koh because I love his Link Style.

[Dawnlight]

I voted for Lynker. A major improvement overall, but like I said before, I don't like the fencing on the right edge of the screen.

[Tree]

Votes for Koh. I don't know what tileset that is, but it's an excellent blend of tiles, colors, and detail. Great job!

[Moo2wo]

I voted Lynker for the same reason Dawnlight did; that is an incredible improvement!

[Jared]

Hey. It feels pretty nice to be in first for once.
This has never happened!

[Shane]

I voted Lynker. As said a major improvement to his previous work!

Edited by Midnight_King, 18 April 2011 - 10:03 PM.

[William]

I nulled, since I'm in it, but had I not entered I would've voted for Koh.

Koh - 7/10
The colors, design, water, etc. It all blends together very nicely.

Lynker - 6/10
I don't particularly like this screen. The fence makes the whole screen a little cramped, the detail is a little too random, and I don't really like the pallete. The screen is certainly functional, but it doesn't flow as nicely as Koh's. If any of that makes sense.

[Chakaa]

I voted Lynker, unlike a lot of people, I like the fence

[trudatman]

underwhelmed. nulled.

[Adem]

Voted for Lynker. The grass at the top of the screen needs work, as it's all the same, but other than that, it's a vast improvement...from all of your previous work. It's a bit cramped toward the bottom right, but it gives it an interesting feel.

[Nathaniel]

Koh - 7/10
Looks pretty good to me. Not sure what else to say.

William - 7/10
Nice autumn GB style screen. Details look just about right.

Lynker - 6/10
Details are good, but the overall screen feels pretty crowded. It looks like something that might flow better if the same thing was expanded over two or more screens. I just feel like it is trying to do more than it can and should handle. Also, fencing along screen edges can sure have a way of forcing you to do more with less, by creating an area too small for what you want to do with it, plus forcing you to try to be more creative (in a cumbersome or less desirable sort of way) with the edges of bordering screens.

They were certainly all good or decent, although nothing too outstanding. I decided to vote for Koh, as I think it has the slight overall edge on appeal, and has the best looking subscreen too, beating out a lack of one and a more standard looking one (although not by much). Subscreens are only for tie breakers in my book, though.

[Xenix]

Voted for Lynker. Nice improvement there buddy! Keep up the good work and you'll get an immense amount of skill with zc in no time! Practice practice practice, that's all i did for a year. Now I have a pretty good grasp on the screen design process. You keep building up your skills, and you'll be pretty beast with zc.

[Bourkification]

I voted for William; your screens look ten fold better now that it isn't a JPEG. I can actually see the detail!

[chainswap]

I voted Lynker, unlike a lot of people, I like the fence

i also agree the fence looks fine to me