43 replies to this topic

[DarkFlameWolf]

null vote since mine is not in there. j/k

[Wild Bill]

Blonde799: Is that mountain ledge really big enough to create that much of a shadow? Fresh looking tiles, though. The part I don't like is the mountains. They just don't work for me.

skateboarder11: Where are those waterfalls coming from? Waterfalls normally fall from the edge of something, not from the sky.

BH4: Looks nice.

Mr. Z: Nice looking puzzle.

Nick: Looks good, but I'd do something about that layered sign thingy, where its post is in front of the bridge. You might move the bridge to the left to take care of it, or maybe shift the river turn to the right by eliminating two trees in the upper right corner.

Petoe: Looks nice. There's actually tree variety (some with leaves, some without), which is something I've not seen much in winter shots.

Hero Link: Glad you got the mountain ledges fixed up since you showed me that shot on AIM. Looks good.

I don't know who to vote for, so I'm just going to null vote.

[skateboarder11]

The waterfalls will start on the screen above that, that is on the bottom half of the overworld.

[link3505]

BH4 got my vote, simply becuse he gave me those tiles, and they frigging pwnzorz

[Stungun]

NOTE: Chart might not come out right.

+++++ Originality Looks Effort Cleverness Comments
Blonde799 +++ ++ ++ = Nice shot. The shadows are incomplete, on that outstretched cliff, there. You could have put a little effort on shadowing the edges.
Skateboarder11 - + ++ = Nothing special. At least it works, but you could have made it more detailed. It's a little bland for that tileset.
BH4 +++ ++ +++ ++ Nicely done, with the pose, and the village is well done. Great attention to detail.
Mr. Z + + ++++ +++ Good marks on effort and cleverness. One thing I gotta hand to you, you always make great dungeon puzzles.
Nick ++ - ++ = The pallette is way too dark. It may be nighttime, but nighttime or not, you need to be able to see. Lighten the pallette a LITTLE.
Petoe ++ ++ +++ + Nicely done. The snow is well-placed, and I see edited tiles to accomodate the snow. Very well done.
Hero Link - = + = ...A remake of LTTP? In ZC? That pallette, as Nick's, needs to be lighter, IMO. But yours is lighter at least.

TOTAL MARKS:
Score will be measured by adding the scores of all the categories.
Blonde799 +++/++/++/= +++++++ (+7)
Skateboarder11 -/+/++/= ++ (+2)
BH4 +++/++/+++/++ ++++++++++ (+10)
Mr. Z +/+/++++/+++ +++++++++ (+9)
Nick ++/-/++/= +++ (+3)
Petoe ++/++/+++/+ ++++++++ (+
Hero Link -/=/+/= = (0)

BH4 wins my vote mostly for originality and effort.
Second place is Mr. Z.
Third is Petoe.

Honorable mentions:
Most Original: Tie: Blonde799/BH4
Best Looks: 3-way tie: Blonde799/BH4/Petoe
Most Effort: Mr. Z
Most Clever: Mr. Z

[Neppy]

Well I think the best looking pic has to go to BH4. I like how this shot looks. It was a very hard choice this week. All of the screens look great.

[IaN]

It came down to BH4's and Petoe's, but I ended up voting for Petoe's. The fact that it (for once) isn't like that here, I like the screenshot a lot more (Petoe loves snow, I'm not very fond of it....at all. Usually) and since he's using the B-Rang that I semi-made, I had to vote for it. Besides, it looks great too.

[zoraman]

Seeing these SD3 graphics submisions has made me want to make a screen shot..I'll enter in next weeks contest.
I might even use some of my drawn graphics...I'll think about what I'm gonna do but prepare to stain your pants because of the beauty of my picture.

[Stungun]

but prepare to stain your pants because of the beauty of my picture.

*drops heavilly colored red soda on his trousers*

[Peteo]

Good shots this week.

Whoa, BH4! That's an awesome shot! And the blur actually makes it look even better.

Petoe: Nice winter screen. And anyway, what is that thing near the crystal? O_o

Heh. It's just an... weird looking enemy.

[zoraman]

QUOTE (zoraman @ Dec 25 2003, 12:41 PM)
but prepare to stain your pants because of the beauty of my picture.  

*drops heavilly colored red soda on his trousers*

Need a towel?

Edited by zoraman, 25 December 2003 - 10:09 PM.

[ShadowTiger]

Seeing these SD3 graphics submisions has made me want to make a screen shot..I'll enter in next weeks contest.
I might even use some of my drawn graphics...I'll think about what I'm gonna do but prepare to stain your pants because of the beauty of my picture.

AAAH! *runs from Zoraman 'Cuz he knows he can do awesome things*

[zoraman]

Need I say more?

[Peteo]

Unfair! Your's animates, Zoraman. But still, don't be so sure about your victory...

Oh, and shouldn't we be talking about this week's shots here instead of next week's?

[HappyPuppet]

Need I say more?

Yah, like why you're going to submit something you've submitted before.