My favorite is Joelmacool's, but Avataro's is the only screen without design issues, so my vote went there.
Joelmacool: Ladders and pot are purple? I understand you are replicating the border-to-interior transition with the mountain tiles, but now there is an air gap which seems a bit too much since there's not even a color change. I do love the visuals, and the palette, even if it could use more non-purple colors.
Kivitoe: A good start, but all those tile errors where the bricks don't line up hurt. Maybe put a simple black outline between them, and perhaps make one type slightly darker than the other? The torches look like someone removed the fire and didn't bother to repair the bowl, and the lava is a solid color.
Avataro: The idea's pretty simple, but hey, no design flaws.
I had a pretty cool idea for this competition, but it's too late to submit now I could still make it I guess, but...
Edited by Cukeman, 29 July 2016 - 02:38 PM.