56 replies to this topic

[Avaro]

Yes, scripting is more diverse than only custom enemies and custom bosses. I'm fine with the entire list, except the part about scripting being split into just custom enemies and custom bosses. I'd suggest including item of the year too (but that'll break the limit).

 

I'd still prefer "Most Anticipated Quest" rather than "Project of the Year" since a highly-anticipated quest doesn't necessarily have to be part of a project.

 

I actually think by "project" they mean a quest that is or was in production. You anticipate quests that are yet to be done, thus they are still in production.

[DCEnygma]

How about since we already have Best Overworld and Best Dungeon, maybe we remove the seemingly redundant Best Mapmaker and replace it with Custom Item of the Year?

[nicklegends]

Yes, scripting is more diverse than only custom enemies and custom bosses. I'm fine with the entire list, except the part about scripting being split into just custom enemies and custom bosses. I'd suggest including item of the year too (but that'll break the limit).
 

 
I actually think by "project" they mean a quest that is or was in production. You anticipate quests that are yet to be done, thus they are still in production.

Right, but isn't the whole point of the category to cover quests that haven't been completed yet?

[DCEnygma]

I'm not opposed to keeping it as Most Anticipated Quest. I don't know that there's many projects in development that wouldn't be quests at this point anyways.

[David]

I honestly believe the list is great and provides an extensive and ample range of recognition, which is superb. Looking forward to the Superlatives!

[DCEnygma]

Updated List

 

General

• Forum Topic of the Year
• Non-ZC Project of the Year
• Highest-Quality Posts
• Chat Member of the Year
• Forum Member of the Year
• Member You Would Hang Out With for a Day
• Funniest Member
• Broadcaster of the Year
• Staff Member of the Year
• Most Likely to Become Staff
• Most Mature Member
• Most Artistic Member
• Newcomer of the Year
• Most Likely to Talk to Oneself in Chat
• Most Modest Member
• Most Changed Member
• Most Helpful Member
• Most Ambitious Member
• Sexy Beast!!!
• Sir Issac Newton Award: Most Intelligent Member

Zelda Classic

• Quest of the Year
• Tiles of the Year Pixel Artist of the Year Spriter of the Year
• Tileset of the Year
• Music of the Year
• Scripter of the Year Custom Enemy of the Year
• Custom Boss of the Year
• Best Puzzles
• Best Graphics
• Best Soundtrack
• Overworld of the Year
• Dungeon of the Year
• Storyline of the Year
• Malevolent Creator
• Most Improved Content Creator
• Best Let's Play
• Most Anticipated Quest Project of the Year
• Best Mapmaker Custom Item of the Year
• Most Thorough Beta-Tester
• Most Innovative Design
• Most Promising Newcomer

 

[Dawnlight]

Actually, there is one thing I did notice. Why is "Original Content of the Year" omitted in ZC?

[DCEnygma]

Well, its basically broken into multiple categories.

[Aevin]

I think I'm completely on board with that list, personally.

[nicklegends]

I think that's an A+ list.

[Omega]

Best first quest?

[DCEnygma]

Alrighty! I think we're good to go with this list, so I'm going to close the topic. Nominations will be open on Monday, so start thinking about who you want to nominate for each topic now, and thanks for everyone's assistance!