33 replies to this topic

[Jupiter]

Jupiter: The tile itself is good enough, but you placed it in a cset which made it green. And green stones are somewhat rare and look funky to me. Just my feeling about it. Most of the voters didn't notice, nor bother, so it's seemingly fine.

I agree that a green boulder or green stone is kinda strange actually...but I think we've been conditioned to think they are normal...

Edited by Jupiter, 22 April 2010 - 10:20 AM.

[Twilight Knight]

Logically voted for Jupiter 'cause it's awesome. Catfriedrice would be second.

[Nathaniel]

Jupiter - 7/10
Another nice shot from you, although I wonder if a slightly higher horizon line would look better.

lightdestroyer - 7/10
A very nicely detailed screen with a subscreen that also looks very nice.

Sheik - 7/10
Very good design and ground details. Nothing to really complain about, so the rest is just about overall appeal.

catfriedrice - 6/10
Not a bad screen. Just not as good as the other three, pretty much. However, I find the subscreen portion to be unique and interesting. I like its organization. Something different, but not off the wall either.

I chose lightdestroyer this time as a close favorite. Not a popular choice I see based on the vote totals, but I don't necessarily roll that way.

[Mitchfork]

Jupiter - 35 votes = [76.09%]
lightdestroyer - 3 votes = [6.52%]
Sheik - 7 votes = [15.22%]
catfriedrice - 1 votes = [2.17%]
Total Votes: 46

Jupiter

Climbing the small island of Kahului.

Congratulations Jupiter!