43 replies to this topic

[link3505]

HeavyTitanium

*Link is mad cause he had to go outside in the rain*

IaN


Moonwhisper

"Thank freakin' Din the name is no longer Woods of Winter!"

newbydude

A cave in a tree! How strange.

Shoelace

Welcome to the Fairy Springs.

[Rocksfan13]

Gotta go with Shoelace on this one. Love those trees!

[ElLibertador]

OOooooo...those trees, Shoelace, are so cool . I'll vote later. I just wanted to comment those trees.

Edited by LinkMystro, 17 September 2007 - 02:31 PM.

[Professor Bedwetter]

I vote for... ME



No I really vote for IaN. It looks just so *no word can describe it*


Runners up are HeavyTitanium!


Shoelace for some reason I just Don't like yours...

[Titanium Justice]

I would of realy liked to vote for me but Ian's screenshots is fantastic!!!!well maybe ill vote for me some other time

Edited by HeavyTitanium, 17 September 2007 - 02:37 PM.

[CastChaos]

I voted Shoelace.

HeavyTitanium: This is a very close second. The house's placing and surrounding is great and the overall feel is very exciting, somehow reminds me for the SotW winners of the past...

IaN: Well, this is something that REALLY reminds me of the past of SotW... Great screen, but nothing astounding for me now.

Moonwhisper: Nice, a little unique, too. Probably great to play, but not a vote now. I somehow like the holes.

Newbydude: Not bad, but the massgrown bush area covers too big portion of the screen without adding anything to it. The ground detail is somehow lifelike. Somehow.

Shoelace: Look at those trees! They were intentional,or they just jumped in the screen? Too good. I also like transparent water (Was there somebody who didn't know that?) and the mountain layout hints for the interesting base layout of the area. Plus there are planks despite the fact that Link can swim? Must... resist... speculating...

[Plissken]

Shoelace all the way. The water and trees are just amazing.

[Dawnlight]

It's either IaN or Shoelace. But my vote goes to Shoelace for creativity. And the "prettiest" of all of the screens.

[Mitchfork]

Gotta go with Moonwhisper on this one. Sorry, but newbydude's and HeavyTitanium's shots are just basic DoR/Pure shots that we've seen eleventy-billion times (not to mention tile errors in Heavy's). IaN's is pretty, but nothing more, and Shoelace's just has too many conflicting styles.

[The Satellite]

Shoe.
lace

!!!

Voted for that one spectacular shot.

[DarkFlameWolf]

no clue why anyone is voting Shoelace. The trees alone can't carry that shot in my eyes. Its too cluttered and very confusing. No real good design aesthetic other than, 'let's clutter up the screen so its detailed!'
Ian is the clear winner here. Not just for graphics used, but in a decent screen design with perfect balance between solid areas and open playable areas. It just flows well. Nobody else comes even close this time.

[The Satellite]

I don't like the shape of IaN's shot.

[CastChaos]

IaN is just mountain, tree and some ground detail. Nice graphics, but there needs m-o-r-eeee...

The feeling counts what you feel when looking at the screens... Shoelace and HeavyTitanium pulled off nice rich feel, Moonwhisper's screen makes me remember very old games. Newbydude's screen makes me remember myself in the early days...

[ElLibertador]

After carefully examining, I've made my choice. I never much liked Shoelace's shots. Too cluttered and clashing, and some other little details I won't B**** about...but those trees are amazing. I don't like HeavyTitanium's shot (although the design is nice)...tiles are used weird, rain is repetitive. Newbydude's is just not to my liking. Moonwhisper actually has a nice shot...but IaNs is cooler. The subscreen is very nice, and the screen looks nice.

Edited by LinkMystro, 17 September 2007 - 04:23 PM.

[Old Inactive Member]

This weeks review by a purezc member

HeavyTitanium:

2 thigs wrong with the shot
1. the water tiles are used wrong (well it looks lke it
2. whats that in the top right corner



IaN:

not bad mabey a few flowers on the screen or somthing that will problay make it better



Moonwhisper (vote) :

Nothing worng this shot looks great espicaly since you are doing a OOS remake


Newbydude :

the shot is too orgied too boxed to stright and un natural looking



Shoelace :

Custom GFX isn't everything but it is a good shot but i don't like the tarsprented water there is yoo much detile below it


Billy out