I voted for Cukeman. Nice use of classic, and enhanced in a good way. I like.
Shoshon I feel could give his tiles some more detail. I like his screen layout however, and the theme as well.
Ennon also has a good layout, and I’m a fan of the water. However, the grass is suffering, tbh, and the house looks like it’s pasted on to the mountain. You have a good start, just work on the tiles more imo.
The tileset is less then a month old.
"the house looks like it’s pasted on to the mountain" Have you ever noticed that about Oot? Because that is my 2d recreation. And I feel it would be off to make the building pop out of the cliff wall. Because like in Oot, the build is just a hallway to a pond for fishing. I don't think I would be fishing in a house. What a fish tank, lol.
Any suggestions on whats needing fixing in the grass?
Because I don't want to recreate sd3 grass, and have no love for the toxic moss look of the flat green tile.
Zc palette system is limited to main and one level palette at a time. And all my main is maxed out.
I feel they need 2 or 3 darker shades to make a few details to pop, and to create a shadow-line What I try to do to give a non outline. which is really hard to do in such a small space and limitations on colour's.
I unlike some, I want and can take Positive\constructive criticism..
Edited by EnnonFenom, 18 April 2018 - 09:59 AM.