Screenshot of The Week 178
Started by
Teilyr
, Sep 23 2007 04:35 PM
47 replies to this topic
#16
Posted 24 September 2007 - 04:29 AM
Voted for /M/.
The palette is very interesting and the perspective is very exciting... I love when lower things are actually smaller.
TriMaster: Nice gameplay screen.
The Satellite: Super layout, plus I like snow.
Evan the great: Nice lights, nice palette, what an MC feeling... ...in this otherwise general screen.
Ebola Zaire: At first, I thought this was an ordinary screen, but then I realized the great mountains. I like the entrance and stairs tiles, too... plus I love that big tree on the left.
The palette is very interesting and the perspective is very exciting... I love when lower things are actually smaller.
TriMaster: Nice gameplay screen.
The Satellite: Super layout, plus I like snow.
Evan the great: Nice lights, nice palette, what an MC feeling... ...in this otherwise general screen.
Ebola Zaire: At first, I thought this was an ordinary screen, but then I realized the great mountains. I like the entrance and stairs tiles, too... plus I love that big tree on the left.
#17
Posted 24 September 2007 - 07:01 AM
Trimaster001: Nice screen. Looks detailed and sweet.
The Satellite: Really empty, you should put some walkable rocks&stuff in the snow.
Evan the Great: Lovely palette, but those walls look..., strange and the light beams as well.
Ebola Zaire: Great, but the mountain tiles have a really soft brown. Like there made of hot chocolate instead of rocks.
/M/: Nice mountains. The palette could be better, to light. You also need a link, unless you want the classic one. I'm still not sure the palette has to be that bright(or misty).
Vote: Trimaster!
The Satellite: Really empty, you should put some walkable rocks&stuff in the snow.
Evan the Great: Lovely palette, but those walls look..., strange and the light beams as well.
Ebola Zaire: Great, but the mountain tiles have a really soft brown. Like there made of hot chocolate instead of rocks.
/M/: Nice mountains. The palette could be better, to light. You also need a link, unless you want the classic one. I'm still not sure the palette has to be that bright(or misty).
Vote: Trimaster!
#18
Posted 24 September 2007 - 09:16 AM
Ebola got my vote i love those canyons in that shot!
#19
Posted 24 September 2007 - 10:39 AM
Voted TS. This has nothing to do with friendship, neither.
Evan's, imo, is somewhat normal. Good form, but, the palette seems kinda gloomy to me. /M/'s is, well, incomplete... TriMaster... nice shot, nice shot, definitely, but I typically don't vote for dungeon shots and Ebola... Not caring much for those mountains...
Evan's, imo, is somewhat normal. Good form, but, the palette seems kinda gloomy to me. /M/'s is, well, incomplete... TriMaster... nice shot, nice shot, definitely, but I typically don't vote for dungeon shots and Ebola... Not caring much for those mountains...
#20
Posted 24 September 2007 - 11:04 AM
I voted Evan. Nothing wrong with adding a little bloom to the palette. It makes for a more ethereal atmosphere.
#21
Posted 24 September 2007 - 02:58 PM
I voted for Trimaster001. The screen was awesome with design as the rooms around it fit. As a screen it makes me want to play that game. Very good job.
You can quote me that Trimaster001 is the next Mr. Z.
You can quote me that Trimaster001 is the next Mr. Z.
#22
Posted 24 September 2007 - 03:07 PM
I dont even think i can vote...I love 'em all!
#23
Posted 24 September 2007 - 03:11 PM
I like the way TriMaster001 uses Pure. Therefore, that's where my vote goes.
#26
Posted 24 September 2007 - 11:56 PM
Tri: Still don't like the lights, but it's the best shot this week *votes*
TS: Interesting... not terribly appealing to me though. Not a fan of the hodgepodge of graphics.
Ev: I like it! Surprised this doesn't have more votes
EZ: ... why did you take a shade out of those mountains? They look bad now, and clash HORRIBLY with the black-outlined Pure tiles.
/M/: I don't see the logic in submitting WIPs ... why not finish it THEN submit?
TS: Interesting... not terribly appealing to me though. Not a fan of the hodgepodge of graphics.
Ev: I like it! Surprised this doesn't have more votes
EZ: ... why did you take a shade out of those mountains? They look bad now, and clash HORRIBLY with the black-outlined Pure tiles.
/M/: I don't see the logic in submitting WIPs ... why not finish it THEN submit?
#27
Posted 25 September 2007 - 03:22 PM
EZ: ... why did you take a shade out of those mountains? They look bad now, and clash HORRIBLY with the black-outlined Pure tiles.
#29
Posted 25 September 2007 - 04:26 PM
TriMaster gets my vote, though I'm not crazy about his torches. [shameless plug] Perhaps you'd like the ones from CoD's tileset? [/shameless plug]
No disrespect to the other shots, though. At a critiquing viewpoint..
TS: The trees killed it for me, to be honest. Also, I've never been a fan of Pure's snow.
Evan: Nice shot here. The walls stand out abit too much but, I like the way you've kinda GB'd alot of Minish tiles.
Ebola: Hrm. Looks like you took NoeL's mountains and applied a classic palette to them. I don't like them. At all. Also, the tall grass stands out. Try applying a darker green to it, making it more yellowish, or changing the whole dang cset so it meshes better.
/M/: Nice palette. I can't critique it because it's a WIP.
No disrespect to the other shots, though. At a critiquing viewpoint..
TS: The trees killed it for me, to be honest. Also, I've never been a fan of Pure's snow.
Evan: Nice shot here. The walls stand out abit too much but, I like the way you've kinda GB'd alot of Minish tiles.
Ebola: Hrm. Looks like you took NoeL's mountains and applied a classic palette to them. I don't like them. At all. Also, the tall grass stands out. Try applying a darker green to it, making it more yellowish, or changing the whole dang cset so it meshes better.
/M/: Nice palette. I can't critique it because it's a WIP.
0 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users