36 replies to this topic

[Titanium Justice]

I voted for Moonwhisper, but i almost voted for CastChaos.

[Evile]

Mmm, I'm not really a fan of DoR so I dunno about this week.

CC: nice house, but it's kinda plain for SotW.
Lucas: Palette looks like pee and quite a few tile errors.
MW: looks pretty nice but seems like theres too much going on.
zmaster: Meh, looks kinda strange.

I might vote later, still deciding here.

[LostInHyru1e]

CastChaos - very nice looking shot, but nothing special enough to win this week, sorry.

Lucas92 - Looks good, but once again, doesn't stand up against the competition.

Moonwhisper - Awesome. Vote goes here.

ZMaster - I almost voted here, I really did... the idea for that kind of dungeon is awesome, and I'd very much like to play it. Moonwhisper just beat you by a little.

[Zenith]

Heh. Looks like Moonwhisper stole the show this week.

Yes, the switch is custom...sorta. Used this really complex process of cookie-cuttering the switch's shape into the basic DoR sand tile, then recoloring it...anyway, I'll see if Radien can put it and a few other tiles I'm working on into the submitted DoR 2.0. But listen to me blabbing on...

And in a few days I might have to say where that dungeon name came from...

[Nathaniel]

CastChaos - 8/10
I think it is an awesome room. Everything seems to be well put together and nothing looks out of place. I am sure something else could be added to spice it up a little more, but what exactly is for you to judge. Perhaps something could go on the south wall between the windows. But hey, I would let you redecorate my apartment any day.

lucas92 - 4/10
It is a good choice of tiles, but the overall design is very simple for a high potential tileset. I am not seeing much creativity. Try to look at how the best designers make cliffs and buildings, and you might get some good ideas and of course choose what you can work with. Keep it up. With the right attitude, you will definitely get better.

Moonwhisper - 7/10
Pretty good. There is a lot of detail without a doubt, although I can't help but find some of it a bit awkward looking, mainly becuase I am having trouble understanding some of what is going on with it. It looks very good for gameplay on the other hand, and I defintely like the use of the overhead bridge. You seem to really stretch yourself with this screenshot, so you deserve a high rating of 7 despite some of my confusion.

zmaster - 7/10
It looks nice and seems to lack flaws in my mind. While it isn't too complicated, it appears to all be placed together well. It is certainly excellent for gameplay.

My gameball goes to CastChaos.

[NoeL]

voted for zmaster.

Moonwhisper's is good, but I think the bridge obscures too much of the screen.

[Twilight Knight]

Looks like everyone chosed DoR this week.
I like the nostalgic pallete and the shot is quite nice so: *vote for Moonwhisper*.

[Mitchfork]

Looks like everyone chosed DoR this week.
I like the nostalgic pallete and the shot is quite nice so: *vote for Moonwhisper*.

Actually, it's "Hint of Ruin." But both palettes are easily among the best in the tileset.

[NineLives]

My vote goes for Moonwhisper because I love crowded screens. (That does not include walls... just heavily detailed.)

[Professor Bedwetter]

I vote Moonwhisper

you just totally owned capcom

[Moonbread]

I don't know if I deserve this victory. The quest file that had that screen went corrupt. Should I still win?

[NineLives]

It depends on the screenshot man, not the quest.

I mean... it's THE SCREENSHOT OF THE WEEK

not quest of the week.

[Nathaniel]

I don't know if I deserve this victory. The quest file that had that screen went corrupt. Should I still win?

A file going corrupt doesn't erase the effort you put into it, so of course you still deserve the victory.

[LostInHyru1e]

As far as I know, you don't even have to intend to use the entered screen for anything in the first place, right?

[CastChaos]

Not a must, but making a screen just for winning SotW leaves some ethical doubts. Still, if you made a screen and intended it for use other than winning SotW, the it's okay, no matter if you can't use that screen in a quest anymore.