28 replies to this topic

[Neppy]

skateboarder11

Yes, I'm still alive.

Pabru

In the deepest depths of the forest, Link is confronted by his worst nightmare. Navi has finally returned.

jimmyb

Yeah, so what... I added a few more colours to Classic, shoot me for it.

Dawnlight

Stay away from my fried chicken Deku Scrubs!

Evile

Random overworld screen ftw!

[Deviance]

I get first reply! Pabru gets it

[Bourkification]

I null'd, I probably would have gone with Pabru though. I love his quote.

[Moonbread]

sb11 for the win. Well, for the temporary tie, at least. Can't detect the errors in Pabru's shot because it's a jpg...

[Alestance]

Theres no grass variation in Pabru's shot, for one.

[Titanium Justice]

I voted for Evile. Looks great!

[Zacron]

Pabru gets my vote, if just for the sheer comedy of the pic.

though they all look great

[King Harkinian]

I like Pabru's shot the best.

[Dawnlight]

I went with Evile this week.

skateboarder11 - 7/10
Pretty nice. The design looks kinda weird.

Pabru - 8/10
Overall excellent design, but you overdid yourself with those ALTTP trees. Plus, that description is just too funny.

jimmyb - 8/10
Expert use of the Classic Tileset

Dawnlight - Russ's Dog/10
Russ's dog is somewhere in the forest! I will use this fried chicken to find him. Now stay away from me Deku Scrubs! (It might be a sidequest in SoD)

Evile - 8.5/10
More like MZC Tileset shot FTW! Excellent shot! Can't wait for your tileset!

[SpacemanDan]

So many great screenies this week. This was a bit of a tough one.

skateboarder11: Interesting, but the classic trees don't look like they belong there, IMO. (Visually, I mean.) Nice work otherwise.

Pabru: Lol at the comment for one. As for the shot, it's good, but I'd add more grass variety. Other than that, nice.

jimmyb: That's some awesme use of the classic set, dood. My only sugestion would be to make the grass corners seem a little less rigid.

Dawnlight: The design is great and I love the palette. I really like it. It just seems to have that charm that I can't put my finger on. Awesome stuff. *Votes*

Evile: Nicely designed screenie you got there. I've got no complaints.

[Joe123]

It was a choice between Tri and Evile, but seeing as Evile's has less perspective issues and it doesn't use those weird tentacle things that I never liked, it gets my vote.

[MrMister]

Voted for Dawnlight this week.

Skateboarder11 - Great "demo tileset" screenshot! Great use of color!

Pabru - Love the caption, unfortunately not enough to save your bland, but solid, screenshot.

jimmyb - Great classic shot! Sometimes a great design is better than a horribly designed shot with great graphics.

Dawnlight - See this is what I mean by great colors, design, and graphics!

Evile - Great shot, but the screen looks a little bland and the colors bother me...

[Adem]

I'm loving Pabru's shot.

[Prophecy Face]

I voted for Dawnlight, although I do see the perspective issues Joe123 talked about. But hey, it's Zelda... That's a valid excuse, right?

[Mitchfork]

skateboarder11: 6/10
It's decently designed, but the snow gets in the way of the shot too much for me to really like it. I know that's purely because of the fact that we can't see it in action, but I judge what I can see.
Pabru: 6/10
The darker shadows really obscure the edges and the transparency doesn't create good-looking colors and as others have pointed out, the grass isn't used optimally. Design-wise it's fairly standard... it's decent, but not much else.
jimmyb: 6/10
I have a hard time judging classic screens... you did a good job of creating more natural-looking mountains on the left side of the screen, but they become flat in the bottom-right corner again. The colors are attractive, though.
Dawnlight: 7/10
I really don't like how the shadows look inn this palette. They don't appear deep- maybe you should use a darker shade for them so that the shadows pop more. Otherwise, it's a well-designed screen that looks highly playable.
Evile: 9/10
Everything in this shot gels together. The palette is vibrant without being overbearing. I love the attention to detail here, like how the puddle lies in the middle of the dirt- which would logically be the lowest point in the shot. Anyone can see that a lot of thought and effort went into this and the payoff was large.