87 replies to this topic

[Rover]

EDIT: Wow nice job ninjaing me Pokemonmaster64

In other news, Koh there is no image to my screen.

Edited by Rover, 09 October 2011 - 02:14 PM.

[Moosh]

I see what you did there, ROFL. I wonder if that'll get taken down xD.

I certainly hope it doesn't but I wouldn't be surprised. I wasn't even sure it'd get accepted.

[Jared]

So it looks like not enough people picked up on the phallic shape of the mountains in my shot.

Take a look at it using the dirty half of your brains. I'm so mature!

....OH MY FREAKING GOD
I love it
xD

[Nathaniel]

Nocturne - B+
Simple, different, yet very interesting. I like.

Shane - F
You're doing it wrong.

Fireblast124 - C-
Friendship may be magic, but this screen isn't. Points for humor though.

Koh - B
A well designed screen, and great by any quest standard, but for SotW, it isn't the most interesting thing you will find.

Yoshidude - B
Repeat what I said about Koh's screen.

Pokemonmaster64 - B+
Interesting color scheme you got there, and pretty good design for classic.

William - B-
Nice winter theme. One major element bothers me though: The ledges are supposed to represent elevation change, and certainly with the cave entrance there. Unless the ice is on a slope (which ZC can't work with well), that passing doesn't represent the same sort of elevation increase, thus that element of the screen seems to contradict itself.

Feenicks - B+
Interesting take on classic, and I like the mountains. Good effort.

Twilight_Knight - B+
Looks better than your previous SotW screens with these graphics. The details are definitely an improvement.

CastChaos - B-
A pretty good screen when it comes to the finer details, although the right side with the upper and lower ledges does feel awkward to me.

Rover - F
Joke shots are old.

There were several good screens this week, but nothing was out of this world. I decided to go with Feenicks this time, as I found it to be the most interesting take on classic among those.

[William]

WOW A PENIS LAWL ITZ CUMING ISNT IT.

Anyway, I probably would've went with Koh if I hadn't entered. I like the palette, design and detail.

Pokemonmaster64 - B+
Interesting color scheme you got there, and pretty good design for classic.

Penis = Great design XD

Edited by William, 09 October 2011 - 02:16 PM.

[The Satellite]

Nocturne - The perspective is just all wrong. The background is flat and makes the screen look like your typical top-down ZC dungeon screen with those block tiles. But that's why it's a problem: You can't have a good side-scrolling section if every section looks like it's a top-down section. I think you need some different block tiles with a different perspective, or shadow the background, or... something.

Shane - Should've had a background. Could've been funnier that way. Slightly funny, but... meh.

Koh - You did very well on this screen. I honestly can't find anything about it I'd change except maybe the water below, and it just looks good overall. Nicely done.

Yoshidude - Admittedly, you use the BS tileset better than some I've seen. Better than me, that's for sure. No real complaints here, except the bush at the bottom of the screen. That could impede movement if something's not blocking it on the screen below it. And if there is... ... then cutting the bush and walking through there means you'll have your movement impeded on the next screen as well. So yeah, just fix that up and you're good.

Pokemonmaster64 - I was gonna say it's just an average screen with kind of a monotonous palette, then I discovered what it really was. ... real mature. So I keep my original judgment.

William - Nice screen, though it seems pretty iffy perspective-wise. The frozen "haters" though? Now that's a good reference. And pretty well executed.

Feenicks - My vote went here. A very nice shot in terms of layout, and I love the palette. It looks pretty smooth. It's just the Link and Octorok sprites that seem to stand out a bit negatively, but it still gets my vote.

Twilight_Knight - Pretty good flow, but the flower tiles seem a bit... well, I dunno. Unnatural? Eh, it's a minor gripe. The shot is nice overall though; nicely done.

CastChaos - The platform on the right seems somewhat odd perspective-wise, but other than that, well, not much to say about it. It's a solid, average dungeon shot. That's all there is too it.

And that wraps it up for this week. Also:

I don't have a dirty part of my brain.

Blatant lies.

[Nathaniel]

WOW A PENIS LAWL ITZ CUMING ISNT IT.

Anyway, I probably would've went with Koh if I hadn't entered. I like the palette, design and detail.
Penis = Great design XD

You could say I didn't look at it long and hard enough.

/me shot

[William]

You could say I didn't look at it long and hard enough.

That whole screen is becoming, isn't it?

[Moosh]

[15:25] <Pokemonmaster64> @8ball Will my screen win?
[15:25] <WildBillBot> Pokemonmaster64: It is decidedly so.
[15:25] <Pokemonmaster64> You guys heard the man
[15:25] <Pokemonmaster64> Get voting!
WildBillBot endorses my screen.

You could say I didn't look at it long and hard enough.

/me shot

I lol'd.

Aside from me making a statement, being immature, ect, I liked CastChaos' and Nocturne's screens a lot. Nocturne's had some perspective issues looking at it from the usual viewpoint, but I think it could work out OK, personally.

That whole screen is becoming, isn't it?

THE PUNS! THE PUNS!

Edited by Pokemonmaster64, 09 October 2011 - 02:31 PM.

[The Satellite]

Well everyone else is doing puns on Pokemonmaster64's screen so I'm going to add one that's both the opposite of clever and also unoriginal to boot!!

[William]

Pokemonmaster's screen is filled to the brim with salty win.

Edited by William, 09 October 2011 - 02:46 PM.

[The Satellite]

Oh and how could I forget Painis Cupcake!



Also Rover wanted me to review his screen so here we go:

It's the Superman 64 of SotW screenshots.

There you go, enjoy your review. <3

[SubconsciousEye]

Oh look, I am not even getting any votes, I am a happy person right now...

I nulled voted, if I didn't enter, I probably would've voted for William...

Edit: Truth to be told, I only entered because of the meme and I don't expect myself to win anyway

Edited by Fireblast124, 09 October 2011 - 03:22 PM.

[Sheik]

So it looks like not enough people picked up on the phallic shape of the mountains in my shot.

Take a look at it using the dirty half of your brains. I'm so mature!

It looks mis-shaped. You should've made it symetrical.

[Supindahood]

So it looks like not enough people picked up on the phallic shape of the mountains in my shot.

Take a look at it using the dirty half of your brains. I'm so mature!

Ah, i can see it now. dat ass