14 replies to this topic

[Neppy]

Octorockoncrack

Old and decrepit, this shrine of the lake is full of wisdom. *Flop

Shane

Link finds a house in a remote area of Hyrule Field during his travels.

Guardian

A cave...wonder where it leads. And why do I only have a boomerang...?

SpacemanDan

This is experimental. The sprites are mock-ups though getting them to work wouldn't be terribly difficult. The tileset itself however is a slow work-in-progress. Subscreen hasn't been touched yet.

Cukeman

Because.

[Jared]

Dan! I remember I used those same exact Link sprites long ago...and got poked fun at and told that they didn't work with ZC. v.vI voted for SpacemanDan. Great job this week, everyone!

[SUCCESSOR]

Octorockoncrack
It's seems kind of messy and I am not a fan of that subscreen. Other than that it's a great shot.

Shane
I don't have an complaints about this shot. It is very well designed and just looks great. You got my vote.

Guardian
I don't really care for a lot of the tiles in this shot. The mountains look odd, Link is sort of odd too, and that tall grass is plain hideous. It's a very well put together shot though. And why do those trees have tiny shadows?

SpacemanDan
It all looks good. If I didn't like Shane's shot so much I would have voted for yours. I think the different colors of ground looks a little funny but it's not an issue.

Cukeman
A little chaotic and needs a new palette. I like it a lot.

Edited by SUCCESSOR, 04 September 2012 - 02:55 AM.

[Rambly]

Call me insane, but I voted for Octorokoncrack because I legitimately like looking at it the most. It's a dark watery dungeon shot! It's different! It's not green! It's not self-consciously "beautiful", but it's striking and has its own unique vibe all its own and it still looks pretty good and that makes it speeeeeecial.

SpacemanDan's is a close second, but I feel like... the brown in the mountains is actually not contrasted enough and the grass doesn't have enough detail. The tiles and aesthetic are new, though! I give you props for that!

[The Satellite]

Octorockoncrack - I like the shape and the layout, but not the colors on the wall. They stand out in a bad way, and kind of clash with the rest of it. It keeps drawing my eye, and not in a good way either.

Shane - Voted here. It captures an ALttP feel very well, it looks nice, and it's well-designed. One thing I'd suggest is that the dirt path at the top is perhaps a little too wide, but that might be excusable depending on the area.

Guardian - It's well put-together, but I don't like the tiles, especially the trees; they just look odd, and I'm not a fan of really big trees, because all they tend to do is obscure the view, especially on screens with enemies where they vanish behind the tree and you don't know where they are.

SpacemanDan - Similar issue with the trees, something also seems off with the diagonal and right-facing mountains at the top left, I'm not sure what it is. Otherwise, though, it's a very neat shot, I would have voted for this but Shane's just barely edged you out. D:

Cukeman - Looks pretty good, like something straight out of the games.

Also three usernames end in "an" and there's an "an" in "Shane." Octorockoncrack, y u mess up this pattern? ლ(ಠ益ಠლ

[strike]

I really like Cukeman's shot although I can't really pinpoint why. Very classic looking. Nice balance of colors. It has actual content. It conveys a mood with a minimalistic amount of tiles.This is the generic shot you want to have, If every screen in you're game looks like this, you're well off. I voted for Cukeman

-Strike

[Dawnlight]

Voted for Guardian. Sepulcher's tileset is becoming one hell of a tileset.

[Jenny]

Hard to decide whether to vote for Shane, Jared, or Octorockoncrack.

But in the end, I ended up voting for Octorock.

[macman1134]

SpacemanDan got my vote only because this is SCREENSHOT of the week. The genera layout captures my eye, with the modified sprites and such (the exception being the dirt tiles-they seem a little out of place). This is a unique idea and a great screenshot; I hesitated choosing it because I personally don't believe that this screenshot could be "played" with zelda classic, bringing back the point of SotW. Great job, again, with the shot!

[Octorockoncrack]

Octorockoncrack
It's seems kind of messy and I am not a fan of that subscreen. Other than that it's a great shot.

Messy? Well, seeing as how it's an ancient temple, I wouldn't think that everything would be as it was back when the temple was built.

Octorockoncrack - I like the shape and the layout, but not the colors on the wall. They stand out in a bad way, and kind of clash with the rest of it. It keeps drawing my eye, and not in a good way either.

I actually like the way that the yellow on the wall stands out. I can't really say why, I just do. And this is just a default palette in PTUX, so it looks like that with almost every dungeon palette.

Anyways:

Octorockoncrack: Pft, this guy. 1/10

Shane: I really like the way you can use those mountains, Shane. Nice tile placement and the overall feel of the screen is very pleasant. 9/10

Guardian: I like the way this tileset is coming along, but i feel like all the tiles together kind of clash a little. Maybe it's just me, but I do like it a lot. 8/10

SpacemanDan: You would have gotten my vote this week if I hadn't nulled. The trees in that shot are absolutely breathtaking! The overall graphics are really nice, but the dark color of the dirt might look better if it was lightened a bit. Also, Skyward Trigger 9/10

Cukeman: Looks like a generic GB shot to me, which isnt necessarily a bad thing, but it's a bit bland for SOTW. 7/10

Very nice shots everyone! Except for Octo, that guy has issues.

[aaa2]

Octorockoncrack: Its ok, a screen that would be ok in any game 6/10
Shane: The house clashes (maybe its the shadowing i don't know) else the screen seems ok 4/10
Guardian: Looks good besides that i do not like the Link sprite but still 8/10(voted for this)
SpacemanDan: I would have liked to vote for this but all the sprites seem too much like cardboard compared to the rest. 7/10 (could have been more if the sprites including link would look less like cardboard)
Cukeman: Man what happened to you i saw you post such wonderful gb-screens before but this one i sadly have to say meh 5/10

[NoeL]

Voted for Octo. Not only does it stand out against the awfully monotonous "generic overworld screen" that tend to be favourites in SOTW, but it actually looks pretty cool.

[Shane]

Since people didn't like my Hyrule Field being green, here is the new palette for it!



I hope yous like it!

...On a more serious matter, thanks to those who voted for me. Also if I didn't submit for this week's SotW I would have gone for Octo's, very neat dungeon shot.

(In case people misunderstand or think I'm being snide, the "new palette" comment was a joke. )

Edited by Shane, 07 September 2012 - 11:21 PM.

[SUCCESSOR]

Messy? Well, seeing as how it's an ancient temple, I wouldn't think that everything would be as it was back when the temple was built.

By messy I meant things looked as though they were placed haphazardly. I get less of that sense looking at it now but still think that a large amount of the design detail being made up of "litter" wasn't the best choice. Not that you should worry about my opinion as a great deal of people seem to disagree with me.

Edited by SUCCESSOR, 08 September 2012 - 04:37 AM.

[Neppy]

Octorockoncrack - 14 votes = 34.15%
Shane - 5 votes = 12.20%
Guardian - 15 votes = 36.59%
SpacemanDan - 5 votes = 12.20%
Cukeman - 2 votes = 4.88%

Total Votes: 41

Guardian

A cave...wonder where it leads. And why do I only have a boomerang...?