40 replies to this topic

[Shoelace]

billy ronald

Link heads for the Royal Gaveyard north of the North Froest

CastChaos

D-D-D-Danger, watch behind you; there's a sculptor out to get you! Just watch some Duckballads, hoo-o!

Ebola Zaire

Screw captions.

Evile

BEACH PARTY!!

link1996


LostInHyru1e


Migokalle

Link wanders around Hyrule Field, and stumbles upon a mysterious river

TriMaster001

Is this pond safe for Link to swim on?

[DarkFlameWolf]

Ebola Zaire, bar none. But nice shots all around except for....nah, don't want to beat anyone down.

[Plissken]

Wow, great turn out this week. I'm gonna have to go with Ebola, great graphics with magnificent design, really great job.

[Dawnlight]

Wow another NoeL wannabe.
Ebola Zaire gets my vote!

Billy: (C-) Work on your mountains and it doesn't seem to grab me.

CastChaos: (A-) Nice Tonberry boss. I really hated those enemies in FF.

Ebola Zaire: (A) Did NoeL pass his quest-making skills to you? That is a kick@ss screen.

Evile: (A) Nothing to complain here.

link1996: (C-) Sloppy, Repetitive ground, and very disorganized.

LostinHyru1e: (B+) Nice GB Screen but it's just not grabbing.

Migokalle: (B+) Nice DOR Shot but like LiH, it doesn't grab me.

TriMaster001: I'm looking for feedback rather than votes.

[trucky5]

I had to go with Ebola, although Evile and Migo had some good ones too!

[LostInHyru1e]

Billy Ronald- not exactly "Bad", but definitely not SoTW material.

CastChaos- looks cool, but not great.

Ebola Zaire-

Evile- I dislike the sand much, and the shot really just isn't that special.

Migokalle- Seen the shot already. Not bad, but I'm sure you could've done better.

TriMaster- truly a good screen, but nothing great.

[Mitchfork]

Billy Ronald: Not stellar, to say the least.
CastChaos: It's alright, but a SotW screen, it is not.
Ebola: I'll only say that I'm definitely NOT a NoeL wannabe. (No offense if youhappen to read this, old "chum" )
Evile: One of the better shots this week, but the design isn't as good as what you normally produce.
link1996: Don't use CSet 5 for overworld objects. srsly.
LostinHyrule: Decent. Not really bad, but not really all that good, either.
Migokalle: Another of the better shots.
TriMaster001: Decent, but not great.

[CastChaos]

billy ronald: Seems a little empty, you should put 2x2 trees on the forest brush, too... I like the ALttP mountains though. Also, the graveyard is north from here, but there are already graves? There was a world war recently?

CastChaos: Messy and empty the same time, the boss is only a rip, the scene is weird... Hey, it's mine!

Ebola Zaire: Perfect hit. NoeL smiles at you.

Evile: Amish.

link1996: I see those fella's lack brain. They are chopping treetrunks, plus they are doing it with cow killing blades... But for some reason, I like that screen.

LostInHyru1e: Much simpler than the other GB screens you showed, but at least there's no mountain error...

Migokalle: For SotW, I appreciate screens with less walkability, but otherwise good.

TriMaster001: Thank you for making me realize why I don't like Pure... The Pure trees on the Pure palette are horrible. Faded, inert. That newer big MC tree is quite good (but it's better with DoR palette). Otherwise not bad screen.


Also, Ebola... funny that you mention that my screen isn't SotW worthy (while it IS), while there are some that are really not... And CSet5 is the overworld CSet.

[DarkFlameSheep]

How stupid of me! I cliked Null Vote...

Edited by Nameless, 07 April 2008 - 03:41 AM.

[Old Inactive Member]

billy ronald: Seems a little empty, you should put 2x2 trees on the forest brush, too... I like the ALttP mountains though. Also, the graveyard is north from here, but there are already graves? There was a world war recently?

Well that is the graveyard's Entrace which is north of the froest

Billy Ronald: Not stellar, to say the least.

What do you meen by that

[Taco Chopper]

Ebola. Those cliffs are stunning.

[Moonbread]

Migo'd. I'd sooner vote for someone being himself over a wannabe.

[Eddard McHorn Van-Schnuder]

Well... Ebola has really awesome graphics, nothing to say about that... But the screen DESIGN? Come on... I ceratinly doesen't like it...
I don't want to go... like I did last time... But...
Open corners? Nah... Don't like... and it doesen't fit that shot...
I don't like the lack of walkablillity either...
But other than that... it's an okay shot... it's ceratinly better than most...
But the palette... Mahn... I think it should be a ''have to do'' thing, to change palettes...
Anyways, overall, good shot... even though I don't like everything about it...

CC, I'm guessing that's a boss room... and if it is, I've got nothing against it. Great work!


Link1996... Uhh... Sure, detailed screens are good... but that looks... goofy... Sometimes, goofy is good. like in Radiens tiles... But... not here... NAh, don't like... And wtf did you do in the top right corner? WTF?!


LiH, that's an... okay shot... Nothing more...


TriMaster, I just love that palette... It draws me... But it's a great shot too...


Evile... I've gotten some time to think about your screen after yesterday... Well, it's okay... I just don't like the palette... that's all...

Now, to comment a few comments:

''CastChaos: Migokalle: For SotW, I appreciate screens with less walkability, but otherwise good.''
Now, sure, I respect your opinion... But this is Hyrule Field... Duh... XD

''LiH: Migokalle: Migokalle- Seen the shot already. Not bad, but I'm sure you could've done better.''
First... You've seen the shot? Oh boo hoo... that shouldn't make it any worse... Should it? And... could I make a better one? Sure, I guess I could... I just liked this... and I didn't submit to win this time...
It was only to tease Evile a little bit...
He didn't want any competission, you see... XD
But looks like he didn't need my competission, judging by the votes...
:3

And yes, I'm in a good mood, so I may have forgotten to comment on some of the screens... It's for my own personal good

Edited by Migokalle, 07 April 2008 - 07:21 AM.

[Plissken]

Migo, for great design you don't ALWAYS have to fill every corner. He didn't fill one, big deal. By great design, I'm talking like, incredible eye candy with unwalkable areas, with terrific placed details. And a nonlinear water. Hell yeah that's a great design, are you kidding me?

[Eddard McHorn Van-Schnuder]

Migo, for great design you don't ALWAYS have to fill every corner. He didn't fill one, big deal. By great design, I'm talking like, incredible eye candy with unwalkable areas, with terrific placed details. And a nonlinear water. Hell yeah that's a great design, are you kidding me?

Well... I don't ALWAYS fill my own corners, but I think in this particualry screen, non filled corners looks dumb... Sorry, but that''s my opinion... I don't think there's any ''great design'' inthat screen... But it's stilla great screen and a worhty winner... And it will win... Cause it's better than the other screenshots here...
But yes, it's a good screen... a great screen... But I don't see any great DESIGN in that screen... Two different things, really...