36 replies to this topic

[Neppy]

Orithan

Hal visits Turninga City at the start of his investigation.

Hoff123

I already had full life...

Demonlink

Beautiful preview of my Hylian Tale "Reawakened".

Marco

indeed Patras' are difficult.

Shane

Go home Level 2, you're drunk.

[Shane]

Voted for Marco because it feels refreshing to look at. Orithan's feels a bit generic complete with a off centered passive sub, Hoff123's is a bit symmetrical and we've seen a similar scene from him, Demonlink's has perspective issues with the water (left of the waterfall) and has solid tiles too close to the egde (and blue hearts? )...

 

...and mine is drunk.

Edited by Shane, 06 October 2013 - 11:09 PM.

[Hoff123]

Damn, Demonlink . I nulled, but that's who I would have voted for.

[Marco]

I voted for Shane because he held a gun to the back of my head. I happily clicked for his vote.

 

 

Good shots peoples.

 

Hoff123 came in second, because his shot feels like its the only one with true effort put in that isnt a try hard-

 

It's clean, flows simple, balanced and indeed has some shade to it, I like it. The shade is not overkill, too, like some other classic work I have seen.

Cute colors, too, it really is.

 

This time around though Shane and I have original shots, by means of presentation and gameplay.

 

City - Village - Village - Sidescroller - WTFdiscool

 

Also, you're not selling your subscreens to me people, can't fool your shots like that on me! Minus that, take a look at the DoR screens and its the same stuff from 2008, just recycled. Heavily recycled.

Edited by Marco, 07 October 2013 - 08:52 AM.

[Shane]

I voted for Shane because he held a gun to the back of my head. I happily clicked for his vote.

You forgot to add hash-tags after that statement. I'm disappointed in you.

_{thanks though, you're swag.qst}

Edited by Shane, 07 October 2013 - 08:59 AM.

[Hoff123]

Hoff123 came in second, because his shot feels like its the only one with true effort put in that isnt a try hard-

 

It's clean, flows simple, balanced and indeed has some shade to it, I like it. The shade is not overkill, too, like some other classic work I have seen.

Cute colors, too, it really is.

You don't mean the brown stuff, do you? Because that was actually supposed to be dirt .

[Demonlink]

(and blue hearts? )...

Not every heart has to be red

 

By the way, voted for Marco, very nice use of the Classic Tileset

Edited by Demonlink, 07 October 2013 - 12:19 PM.

[Rastael]

Puh, very hard to decide. Orithan's and demonlink's pics are great!

But I voted for Orithan. I love Town-screens and this one seems to be very interesting. ^^

[Shane]

Not every heart has to be red

But there's still the fact that it looks rather odd.

[runaru]

Voted for Orithan

[Haylee]

Voted for Shane, it had the most swag.

 

Not every heart has to be red

Warning: Slightly Gross Image(Though still SFW, because I'm nice like that. :3)

Spoiler

Your argument is invalid. *runs*

Edited by Goriya, 08 October 2013 - 07:52 AM.

[lardgreen]

I vote for Demonlink ... I like the status bar and the environment

[Shane]

Subscreen of the week anyone?

 

But it seems most people get voted on not because they took the time and effort on the screen but the subscreen. It only dis-encourages to be creative with world design and focus on a flashy subscreen.

Edited by Shane, 08 October 2013 - 08:48 AM.

[Orithan]

Voted for Marco because it feels refreshing to look at. Orithan's feels a bit generic complete with a off centered passive sub, Hoff123's is a bit symmetrical and we've seen a similar scene from him, Demonlink's has perspective issues with the water (left of the waterfall) and has solid tiles too close to the egde (and blue hearts? )...

 

...and mine is drunk.

Subscreen of the week anyone?

 

But it seems most people get voted on not because they took the time and effort on the screen but the subscreen. It only dis-encourages to be creative with world design and focus on a flashy subscreen.

 

I find this complaint to be a bit on the contradictory side, especially when one of your complaints about my screen is centered on the subscreen. I also feel that it is not fair to complain about the number of votes people are getting, as it may unfairly sway votes. How can you be sure that Demonlink is getting all these votes because of his subscreen?

 

Also, what makes my screen feel "generic", especially in comparison to Demonlink's (who has a type of screen that is seen far more often in SotW than mine)? When you criticize somebody's screen; you want to not only tell them what problems you have with it, but also tell them how to fix these complaints. Just telling someone that their screen is "generic" accomplishes neither.

[Avaro]

Hey, subscreens are part of the pictures we're seeing, so they affect the voting too. Sometimes I even vote for a screen because of the subscreen and sometimes I refuse voting for a screen because it has no subscreen or no Link and enemies.

I vote Marco this week for his well-designed sideview screen!