And that from the guy who told me not long ago on another occasion that he neither has a problem with taking critism too serious nor being overly perfectionist.
#1. I could give you reasons, but they are just personal opinions, so it doesn't mean the dungeon is generally less fun. If you are fine with your dungeon then you should be proud of it. Don't let yourself down because someone else thinks otherwise, you are you and you can do things like you want them to be.
#2. This is an unfinished dungeon of a cancelled project, I actually looked into your questfile the day you gave them out and I looked also for secrets to grasp what you planned for it - and didn't find any flags. Joelmacool's dungeon is finished, obviously your unfinished dungeon can't keep up with it. And not long ago you stated that you want to do things your way and wish to get not influenced by feedback as much as before, so what you do right now is exactly what you should stop to do.
#3 Destructive Critism? Seriously? OK, my wording was a bit negative, I in general tend to word things too negative, but I at least didn't say that your dungeon looks like it is no fun. But to call Binx comment destructive is hilarious, or is it not allowed that others can do better than you? I know that you don't mean it like this, but to say that it is destructive that Joelmacool's dungeon looks like a bit more fun is in my opinion really rude towards Joelmacool.
Since it took me forever to write this other replied beforehand. Binx said anything that could be said about your dungeon.