39 replies to this topic

[Nathaniel]

billy ronald - 4/10
It could be spiced up with more detail to help make it look more interesting. The cliffs look very man made as well.

CastChaos - 6/10
The swamp looks all right down to the details, but the color choice for the rain doesn't seem to clash well with the scene. Perhaps some shade of green would be more appropriate so that it better matches the water it falls into.

Evile - 7/10
While I am not a fan of the overall combined colors, the detailing is good. Nice.

fuzzyman - 5/10
It serves its purpose, but not much beyond that. Besides the "IHop", it doesn't look special to me. Some more ground detail could certainly spice it up.

Trimaster001 - 7/10
Looks pretty good. I like the overall detail and everything seems to fit together nicely.

My vote goes to Trimaster001 due to the better color choices, as standard as it looks. Everything else among the two looked just as good to me.

[Old Inactive Member]

The only vote i'll get this week is from myself

Billy: OMG Your shot makes HoD look like classic (Jocking)

CastChaos: Water green, Rain blue make the rain green and that will be better

Evile: There's somthing wrong with those moutions but i don't know what

fuzzyman: Basic pure NEXT!!

TriMaster001: Looking good espicly that pallet (yes i know evile made it)

So here is my rankings:

Billy (1st)

TiMaster001 (2nd)

Evile
and joint 3rd
Cast chaos

Fuzzyman (5th)

[Dawnlight]

It just doesn't seem manly to vote for yourself.

[Colin]

And why should it matter? He can vote for himself if he wants to.

Anyway, I gotta go with TriMaster, Evile had better design, but I really didn't like this one's palette.

[LostInHyru1e]

Billy Ronald - nothing really special, again. Not a bad screen, but nothing special. Oh, and it's in ZQuest.

CastChaos - I don't know why, but the rain looks very off. Don't know how to fix it... sorry. Otherwise, great looking screen.

Evile: Looks great. My vote goes here.

Fuzzyman: Although the "IHop" made me laugh, the screen is void of much detail. Decent screen nonetheless.

TriMaster001: Looks good, but Evile's shot beat you out. Sorry.

It just doesn't seem manly to vote for yourself.

Eh, I've already tried to go through that with him... it doesn't really matter, though. Regardless of what he votes, it's still the battle between you and Evile.

Edited by LostInHyru1e, 23 December 2007 - 07:07 PM.

[Mitchfork]

billy ronald - 5/10

Basic pure NEXT!!

CastChaos - 6/10
I love how you're using the trees, but the blue rain is really throwing me off, and I think the palette is too saturated, especially in the water.
Evile - 7/10
I really love most of your palettes, but this one I gotta say no to. Don't get me wrong, it's good, but... well, you have much better work. Screen design is flawless, though. Excellently done.
fuzzyman - 6/10
It's... just basic.
TriMaster001 - 8/10
This is a shot with great inner detail in a great palette. My vote goes here.

[Professor Bedwetter]

my vote goes to Trimaster *cast vote*
awsome detail.

Fuzzyman add some detail and then it would a perfect shot

[Theryan]

Billy Ronald - I see a lot of improvement from last week. The water could use some detail, and that whole ZQuest things is a bit of a turn-off.

Cast Chaos - A good shot in terms of construction and detail, but that rain clashes with the whole screen.

Evile - Quite good, quite good! Those trees have too much contrast though, and the reddish-brown doesn't go well with the green.

fuzzyman - You need a lot more detail, the house needs to be layered, and the Ihop idea was used by UBP(Noir) back in SOTW 9.

Trimaster - Good shot and colors! /me votes

[Evile]

Ah jeeze TriMaster, I shouldn't have given you all my palettes. Its causing me to lose.

Edited by Evile, 23 December 2007 - 10:35 PM.

[Dawnlight]

That is one cool palette you gave me. Thanks!

Don't forget it's not over yet, it's just 7 more votes.

[ShadowTiger]

TriMaster001's tall grass reminds me of SD3's. I liked the effect.

Same thoughts as everyone else on the other shots though. Nothing interesting to add.

Vote remains anonymous! ^_^

[Taco Chopper]

billy ronald: not very detailed. 4/10

CastChaos: the rain ruins it all. otherwise, pretty good. 6/10

Evile: brilliant. I like it a lot. 8/10

fuzzyman: a lot like billy's. good try. 4.5/10

TriMaster001: So.. awesome! Freakishly great. 8.5/10

so therefore, my vote goes to Trimaster.

[Alestance]

Theres nothing Christmasy for the week of Christmas?

Evile has the best screenshot that I can see...

[NoeL]

Voted for Evile.

and fuzzyman, what's IHOP?

[Plissken]

and fuzzyman, what's IHOP?

:O

It's a pretty nice pancake restaurant, don't know if they have them in Australia though.