22 replies to this topic

[Nathaniel]

Migokalle - 7/10
Another well designed screenshot from Robin.

Prophecy Face - 7/10
Pretty good. Everything seems to be in place and the screen looks complete.

Midnight_King - 7/10
Good choice of graphics and good usage of them.

T. Platinum - 5/10
I don't see those graphics working well for Zelda Classic, but it's still great to see something out of the ordinary for it. Now if you can find a bigger selection of ground details that work with those, then you get to imagine receiving a six pack of Kudos from me.

Beta Link - 5/10
I'm not digging it. It doesn't really catch my interest. I barely see the transition from the edge of the brown portions of the ledge to the cliffs. Perhaps the coloring of the angles of the cliffs could be reworked. Outside of that, the rest of it seems all right.

Migokalle for the win. Seems like the best design out of all of them.

[Shane]

Midnight king: Color loss aside, it looks pretty good. But a few things stand out. The water seems very cluttered. maybe get rid of half the junk there, it might look a bit better. Speaking of water- The edges of the water, where it meets the ground, stand out way too much. It looks like those tiles have a solid black around their edges, rather than transparent. The black edge gets changes the color of the mountains and makes it look... weird. Or maybe its just me. Only other thing, slashables one tile in from a walkable screen border = Bad idea.

YES I know about the color loss. thanks. Yes I was tossing things in the water maybe the leafs can stay, because the Forest is next to 'em. I think its just you . na It looks like there is but its a curly tall walkable plant if you talking about the mountain you can't.


That reepue worths hundred but I'll changed it to ten

Thanks about the comments guys through.

~ Shane

EDIT: My sister deleted the screen .

Edited by Midnight_King, 29 June 2009 - 08:15 PM.

[Titanium Justice]

I voted for Migokalle. Like always, it looks great!

[Prophecy Face]

Lol, of course he said .PNG ... PNG FTW

In this case there's absolutely no difference between GIF and PNG. Zelda Classic screens always use fewer than 256 colors, so GIF format an be used without losing color.

[Twilight Knight]

Yeah, but you should use .PNG for all images, since there is no color loss at any image and the file size is still small. And so, you can better use .PNG everywhere. Plus this very unrelated to the topic. Heh.

[Soarin]

I Vote for Migokalle
I like your village screenshot.

[Zelda Rocks]

I voted for Midnight_King because he has very well done mountains, and water. Well done.

[Neppy]

Migokalle - 21 votes = [58.33%]
Prophecy Face - 3 votes = [8.33%]
Midnight_King - 4 votes = [11.11%]
T. Platinum - 0 votes = [0.00%]
Beta Link - 8 votes = [22.22%]
Total Votes: 36

Migokalle

You got the Kakariko Overhead Sign! ... now where are you going to put it? (Gah, unfinished subscreen!)

Congrats on the win Migo! ^_^