32 replies to this topic

[ShadowTiger]

Oh dear lord... this is just excessive. I would have voted for Mr. Z's sunshine woods, but the name is alarmingly deceptive. I would have thought it was from a swamp or something. I also would have chosen Petoe's, but it used too much blue for the walls. I would have chosen link3505's, but it was a bit too green, and it was just... mostly forest, with a road. The other little effects were cool though. I probably would have voted for Teilyr's, but there wasn't anything at all happening on it. If there was even a little bit more activity there, like a speech, I probably would have clicked its button... I think FlameArrorStar had the greatest chance of me voting for ... FlameArrowStar. He has some great layering stuff happening there, and I want to know approximately how much of that I can walk on. That would be such a great dungeon if it did that throughout.

[Ielen]

Mr Z's screenshot evokes out cool warmth

Rest are not bad too

[phil]

link3505 is smoking the other dudes hineys.

petoe is in second but I never thought that shot was impressive.

Oh well...that's why everyone gets to vote.

[Peteo]

Why do we have to repeat this: If you say something about the screenshots, you have to give reasons why you think how you think. Comments like "The screenie owns you all!!" or "it's not impressive" are not enough. So could you please try to obey the new rule... and of course all the old rules too here?

[DashSim]

Why do we have to repeat this: If you say something about the screenshots, you have to give reasons why you think how you think. Comments like "The screenie owns you all!!" or "it's not impressive" are not enough. So could you please try to obey the new rule... and of course all the old rules too here?

I have no idea if that was directed to me or not, so just ignore this if it wasn't. I did say why I liked his shot, I liked his trees funny little trees. (I also liked the path and everything else in the shot.) It also wasn't like I was putting any of the other shots down. Also note that when I said it wasn't hard to choose, that was because I loved link3505's shot so much (which I also said in my previous post), not because the others where bad. The shots are all good in there own way...I just really like link3505's. Also, when I said it owns you all, I was just having a bit of fun. Am I truly ever serous when I say things like "It owns you all!!!!111"? Also note that I didn't have time to come up with reasons for which shots are good, why I voted or didn't vote for it and such because I had to go to bed in a few minutes.


EDIT: Oh sure, after reading Petoe's post it seems this big post goes to waste. That's just the way it goes, isn't it?

Edited by King Cool Link, 16 October 2003 - 08:23 PM.

[HappyPuppet]

I have no idea if that was directed to me or not, so just ignore this if it wasn't.

I don't think it was. I think it was aimed at System Error.

[Peteo]

In this case, it was directed to System Error and phil.

[Matt]

None of them really caught my eye this time.

Mr. Z - The smiling rock ruined it for me.

Petoe - The cashiers forehead looks odd.

link3505 - The flowers look like fried eggs, and the caption is lacking.

Teilyr - The Triforce (?) pieces on the right side there are colored weird. Some of the pieces of the fringe on the curtain are placed too closely together. The two large tassels look like forks.

FlameArrowStar - The map at the top is too boring. Link doesn't have enough rupees. The room is confusing, and it makes my head hurt.

[FlameArrowStar]

FlameArrowStar - The map at the top is too boring. Link doesn't have enough rupees. The room is confusing, and it makes my head hurt.

Uh... what's so great about Link having alot of rupees? He just spent alot to buy the *spoiler alert*. And your head hurts... There have been many rooms that are more confusing than this one.

Edited by FlameArrowStar, 18 October 2003 - 11:52 AM.

[LinktheMaster]

Uh... what's so great about Link having alot of rupees? He just spent alot to buy the *spoiler alert*. And your head hurts... There have been many rooms that are more confusing than this one.

umm.... Notice who that is from.

[phil]

Ok fine petoe...I didn't like your shot because I think it's very cartoony and sloppy looking, actually very few of your shots have even come close to impressing me.

I don't think their as great as you think they are.

[Peteo]

Thank you, phil

That was the kind of answer I was looking for. And try to remember to give those reasons next time too so that the staff doesn't have to remind you.

[phil]

your welcome, although i didn't think you would appreciate it.

[Praethus]

You'd be surprised at how much people actually want negative feedback. I went out of town Friday and didn't get a chance to close this. link3505 wins. If a SS doesn't mind could they update the pic. I don't have enough time right now.

[a guy and his game]

Mr.Z because it's just cool. Well at least I think it is.