Joelmacool - Really neat shot! I actually really like the bright colours here, and the tree colour variety is really interesting. Nice work.
Eddy - Not gonna lie, it was very difficult to complete this one particular challenge because of the incredibly strict colour limitations. I could've done something much easier, but it's DayDay, and I felt the need to do this (I guess this screen was inspired by Moosh's shot in that one contest).
Maikeru D. Shinigami - Not too bad. There are a couple odd things with this shot, especially the bottom boundaries between the platform and the lava (the platform looks like it just cuts off). Those specific bomb flowers also look quite weird when they're green. I know they're green in TFH, but those particular tiles you used would've looked much better in blue, or else it would just look like some random cacti growing in a lava field.
Orithan - Probably the most interesting one this week IMO. I really like the transition between light and dark here, and I especially like how dead the 2nd screen looks. The overall design works really well with this transition.
Avataro - I honestly wouldn't have thought this was a custom made palette, since it looks almost the same as OoS' Winter palette. The screen itself is alright though, but there doesn't seem to be a whole lot happening and having most of the screen being just mountain tiles doesn't really make the screen look very interesting.
TheBlueTophat - Was it intentional to pick challenge 69? B) Other than that, this is a pretty decent screen on its own, and I like how you use Instrumentality. However, the issue I have is similar to other rebirth-like challenges. I can barely tell the similarities between the images. Besides a very few things, like the middle and bottom left bridges corresponding to the bridge and the ladder in the original shot, this screen looks too different from the original shot, and would probably be better as just a SotW screen instead.
I would've voted for Orithan if I had not entered, but nice stuff this week.